Anne Applebaum: The Only Thing That the Museum of American History Doesn't Do Is Teach History
According to its director, the Smithsonian's Museum of American History needs new plumbing, new wiring and better lighting. So desperately does the building require renovation, in fact, that there is talk of shutting the whole place down for a year or two, of bringing in some fresher architecture, even of designing a "museum for the 21st century." But while they're at it, maybe the curators of this hugely popular, hugely prominent museum on the Mall should also spend some time talking about what, precisely, their museum is for .
I realize this is no easy task. Probably best known to generations of Washington children for its large collection of trains, the Museum of American History is the one part of the Smithsonian that justly deserves to be called "the nation's attic." It collects everything from first ladies' gowns to family photo albums to old ballots. It owns, among other things, Helen Keller's watch, Cesar Chavez's union jacket, Thomas Edison's light bulb, and a copy of Elvis Presley's first album. Its current exhibits explore America's campaign against the polio epidemic, the first 50 years of Disneyland, the impact of Brown v. Board of Education and the music of Latin pop star Celia Cruz.
Just about the only thing that the Museum of American History does not do, in fact, is teach anyone American history. That is, it doesn't tell the whole American story, or even chunks of the American story, in chronological order, from Washington to Adams to Jefferson, or from Roosevelt to Truman to Eisenhower. When the museum was built in 1964, this sort of thing probably wasn't necessary. But judging from a group of teenagers whom I recently heard lapse into silence when asked if they could identify Lewis and Clark, I suspect it's now very necessary indeed...
...I'm sure chronology isn't the hottest thing in curatorial science these days, but a museum that tells a chronological story doesn't have to be full of dusty displays and dull captions. The first room of the museum of totalitarianism in Budapest opens with a bank of television sets blaring fascist propaganda on one wall and a bank of television sets blaring communist propaganda on another. Without a single written word, the dilemma of Hungary in the 1940s becomes instantly clear. Apply the same ideas to the American Revolution -- use music, pictures and, yes, George Washington's candlestick -- and it's possible to fascinate even the most video-numbed modern American. Nor are cartoon characters needed to make U.S. history "relevant" either: The language of the American Constitution is the language of the civil rights movement and the language Sen. Barack Obama used in his speech at last year's Democratic convention. An exhibition on the Civil War would naturally include Confederate flags and symbols, which are still the subject of controversy today.
None of which is to say that the museum needs to chuck out Evel Knievel's motorcycle and Judy Garland's ruby slippers or (worse) put them in a pompous exhibition called "Postwar Popular Culture." Why not stick them on the top floor and jumble them together with the "I Like Ike" buttons," Alexander Graham Bell's telephone and the first sewing machine. Let visitors wander through the nation's attic -- but with a better understanding of how the nation got to be here in the first place.
comments powered by Disqus
- Richard III Really Ate and Drank Like a King
- Where’s the one place in the world where nobody’s messed with WW II relics?
- Secrets of the Clinton Library
- Beloit College is out with its annual list of what freshman know ... Tiny Tim? Carl Sagan? Forget about it.
- India Bans Indira Gandhi Assassination Film
- A prominent historian of science dies and no one takes notice
- A pro-Hamas Left emerges among historians, complains Jeffrey Herf
- Classicist Mary Beard celebrated by the New Yorker as “The Troll Slayer”
- Ilan Pappé praised in Iran as a "prominent anti-Zionist Israeli historian and intellectual"
- It's hard to be an optimist today, but Juan Cole is