Hendrik Hertzberg: Historians for Kagan
[Hendrik Hertzberg is a senior editor and staff writer at The New Yorker, where he frequently writes the Comment, in The Talk of the Town.]
An e-mail from Barbara Weinstein, professor of history at New York University:
Since history operates on many levels, we always have to remind ourselves where the person is situated when we discuss them historically (as you did Elena Kagan in your post on her undergraduate thesis). She did write her thesis under the supervision of Sean Wilentz, and he may have been kindly, but he certainly wasn’t avuncular. In 1981 he was one year out of graduate school, didn’t have tenure, and was probably the most junior person in the department, with no prestige whatsoever by the usual standards. Kagan’s decision to work with him—a very bright and up-and-coming but very young and virtually unknown scholar—may tell us as much about her as the thesis itself.
I was kind of kidding about Sean, who in my experience is more fraternal than avuncular (and more kind than kindly)—more Dr. Who than Mr. Chips—but I take Professor Weinstein’s point: Kagan chose the then obscure and unknown Wilentz rather than opting for someone already famous and well-connected. This goes against the dominant “narrative” (God, I hate that word) of Kagan as a remorseless apple-polisher and power-seeker.
comments powered by Disqus
- Poll: Majority Of Americans Say Obama Is Mixed Race, Not Black
- New technology helps paleontologists see Ice-Age bee in intricate detail
- History textbooks in crosshairs of Australia's curriculum wars
- Archaeologists' findings may prove Rome a century older than thought
- 150 years of medical journals to go online
- She Came All the Way from Melbourne to Attend the OAH
- The 7 Most Popular HNN Videos from the 2014 OAH
- U.Va. Historian Alan Taylor Wins 2014 Pulitzer for Book on Slaves and War -- His second Pulitzer!
- UW Professor Stephanie Camp, 46, feminist historian, dies
- Italian forces in WW2 were not soft and Mussolini wasn't a clown, British historian claims