Meanwhile, in North Korea
Adam: Well, we're studying the causes of the second Korean War and I just don't get it.
Gen. Spears: As I've explained before, Adam, President George W. Bush was obsessed with Saddam Hussein, not to mention with Iraq's oil reserves. He managed to convince most Americans that Iraq was responsible for the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks on New York City and Washington. So, people just weren't paying much attention to the North Korean threat.
Adam: But didn't anyone notice what was going on in North Korea?
Gen. Spears: Oh, yes. Almost every day the media reported North Korea's escalating attempts to get America's attention. But few people seemed to care.
Adam: But what I don't understand is why North Korea was so afraid. Why did it want a nonaggression pact with the United States so badly?
Gen. Spears: You've got to remember, Adam, that North Korea was a completely isolated, paranoid, Stalinist dictatorship. When President Bush took office, he cut off diplomatic talks, included North Korea in a group of nations he called the "axis of evil" and declared a new doctrine of "pre- emptive war." In short, he fulfilled North Korea's worst fears.
Adam: But did the North Koreans really think the United States would attack them?
Gen. Spears: So it seems. By 2003, much of the world feared the United States. Don't forget, Adam, the Bush administration had withdrawn from the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, the Biological Weapons Convention and the International Criminal Court. The president had also decided to deploy an anti-missile system, which everyone knew was aimed at North Korea and China.
Adam: So why didn't the United States just negotiate with North Korea? It seems like they were working hard to get our attention.
Gen. Spears: They certainly were. After they admitted to developing a nuclear weapons program, they disconnected the International Atomic Energy Agency's monitoring cameras, kicked out the weapons inspectors, withdrew from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, restarted an atomic reactor and threatened to end the armistice that halted the first Korean War.
When the United States still ignored them, they shadowed our surveillance planes and started testing missiles, but Bush simply dismissed North Korea as a "regional problem." But as soon as the Persian Gulf War II began, the North Koreans started reprocessing enough plutonium to build nuclear weapons.
Adam: So is that how Yemen got its nuclear weapons?
Gen. Spears: Yes. The people in North Korea were starving and Kim Jong Il was desperate to raise money to buy food. So he sold most of the plutonium on the black market. But he kept enough to build at least five bombs.
Adam: It just doesn't make any sense. Why didn't the United States try to prevent this?
Gen. Spears: Officially, the United States said it refused to reward nuclear blackmail. But many critics believed that our government, driven by a providential sense of destiny, was no longer willing to negotiate with anyone.
Adam: So what do you think actually triggered the war?
Gen. Spears: Hard to say, Adam. North Korea got pretty testy when the United States started planning cruise missile surgical strikes and openly talked of using tactical nuclear weapons to destroy North Korea's artillery positions. When the U.S. government began debating whether to withdraw its 37, 000 troops from South Korea, North Korea realized that, after Iraq and Iran, it was next.
Adam: But didn't South Korean President Roh rule out any military action against North Korea, and even offer big bucks in exchange for the North ending its nuclear program?
Gen. Spears: He sure did, but that didn't matter to President Bush and unfortunately. . ..
Host: I'm sorry, we've run out of time. On that somber note, we'll have to
end this conversation. Thank you, Sam and Adam Spears, we hope to have you back
This article first appeared in the San Francisco Chronicle and is reprinted with permission.
comments powered by Disqus
J. Caramello - 11/28/2003
North Korea is and should be China's problem, not ours. Why are we still in South Korea fifty years after the end of the Korean War? Here we are bribing the North Koreans not to build nuclear weapons and spending untolds millions of taxpayers dollars. We are not and should not become the policeman of the world and I think the people of this country are slowly waking up to this fact. The entire world seems to hold us in utter disdain anyway, so let's go home and let our critics take care of problems in their areas.
Libertarian Larry - 3/23/2003
What pap. My 8th grade kid could do a better job. What schlock. It's really just an hate attack on President Bush. Totally contrived nonsense.
I can't imagine the nightmare if Gore had been able to steal the election. He'd want to "feel" the pain of the terrorists (Yeh, like the 3,000+ who died on 9/11) Gore would use "diplomacy" (ignore the problem and hope it goes away, atleast until you get re-elected (that's what Bill did)).
It's bad enough that the SF Chronk would pay her and publish her oozings, but for HNN to give her a platform...
Lincoln Moser - 3/22/2003
"When the U.S. government began debating whether to withdraw its 37,000 troops from South Korea, North Korea realized that, after Iraq and Iran, it was next." If troop withdrawal is going to cause the next Korean War, then perhaps we should keep troops there.
Chris Messner - 3/18/2003
Well You had me until - "The people in North Korea were starving and Kim Jong Il was desperate to raise money to buy food."
Really? He's desperate to buy food? The man could care no less who he starves, as long as he retains power and his military is kept in high readiness. Attributing this to the reason he would sell weapons on the black market is wishful thinking at best.
BTW, no you didn't have me until then either.
Bill Heuisler - 3/18/2003
The United States provokes some people by simply existing.
Ruth Rosen is determined to indict the U.S. and pardon North Korea no matter what fact she has to avoid, twist or falsify. Her satire is anti-American fantasy not political commentary.
"By 2003, much of the world feared the United States."
Sure, Ms. Rosen, 3000 American dead on 9/11, 26 Sailors dead on the Cole, 19 civilians dead in the first World Trade Center attack, 226 Marines dead in Beirut. We saved a million Moslems from Serbs and liberated 30 million Afganis. Carter and Clinton bent over backwards to trust North Korea and were betrayed.
But we're the feared aggressor in Rosen's world.
Jong Il breaks treaties, fires missiles, digs tunnels under the DMZ and sends armed reconnaisance teams into South Korea, but he's the hapless victim to Ruth Rosen.
The confusion continues, "The president had also decided to deploy an anti-missile system, which everyone knew was aimed at North Korea and China."
Everyone knew? Yeah, like my flak-jacket used to be aimed at armed robbers; like my chain-link fence is aimed at burglars. Ms. Rosen, how the hell do you aim an anti-missile system?
Finally our supposed withdrawal of 37, 000 troops from South Korea is portrayed as provocative. So, stationing the 2nd Marine Division on the DMZ would reassure poor Jong Il, right?
Mrs. Rosen, Sometimes reality is inconvenient to the polemicist, but this anti-American nonsense insults your readers.
- David Rosand, an Art History Scholar Whose Heart Was in Venice, Dies at 75
- NYT interviews Rick Perlstein about his book
- OAH issues a statement in support of the AP standards
- Daniel Pipes says in interview that the absence of anti-Israel protests in Muslim countries is highly significant
- A historian who studies China has discovered an overlooked angle in the debate about the Middle East. Could he have figured out a key reason for Iraq’s failure to defeat ISIS?