The Truman precedent for Bush's eavesdropping
On the morning of April 9, 1952, American flags flew above 88 steel mills across the country, signaling a change in management. The president of the United States, Harry S. Truman, had seized control of the mills, claiming that the intransigence of the private owners would lead to a strike that would cripple US efforts to win the Korean War.
''The president has the power to keep the country from going to hell," Truman told his staff, according to David McCullough's 1992 biography.
Truman was wrong, according to the Supreme Court, in its most extensively reasoned decision charting the limits of presidential power.
The so-called ''steel seizure case" is suddenly in the news again because President Bush is now saying that his powers as president and commander-in-chief -- the justifications cited by Truman -- permit him to authorize wiretaps on US citizens.
Luckily for Bush, Americans who are being wiretapped don't know they're being bugged, and thus can't challenge his powers in court. But when Congress holds hearings on whether the president has exceeded his powers, the Supreme Court's ruling in the steel seizure case will be the closest thing to settled law on the matter.
And the story of the seizure of the steel mills isn't necessarily comforting to Bush.
Truman, like many presidents, tended to view his critics as being incapable of seeing the national interest. And by early 1952, Truman had a lot of critics. His favorability had plunged below 30 percent, largely because of his handling of the Korean War, and he could no longer count on Congress's support.
In addition, his distrust of corporations -- which dated back to his time as head of a senatorial committee investigating World War II profiteering -- led him to believe that owners of steel companies were pursuing policies that would hamper the war effort. The steelworkers' union was engaged in bitter negotations for pay increases, but management seemed only too willing to accept a strike.
By some accounts, Truman feared that a strike would be used by the owners to drive up prices; the military, in the midst of a munitions buildup, was by far the biggest customer of steel, and would be the biggest victim of a strike.
Congress considered taking action to block the strike but did not, though the Taft-Hartley Act would have allowed Truman to order a three-month ''cooling-off" period.
Declaring that both sides were sufficiently deadlocked as to make a cooling-off period useless, Truman ordered a government takeover of the mills. He said American lives depended on it.
Truman said he was acting to avert a wartime emergency. He cited Article II of the Constitution, which says ''the executive power shall be vested in the president," and that the president ''shall be Commander-in-Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States."
The Supreme Court declared that Truman had exceeded his authority, but its inability to reach a consensus reflected the extraordinary difficulty of setting constitutional boundaries for a president's power. Three justices filed their own concurring opinions, suggesting different ways to gauge the limits of presidential power. Three justices dissented.
The majority opinion, by Justice Hugo Black, concentrated on separating the president's powers from Congress's powers. Black made much of the fact that Congress could have chosen to seize the mills and did not, suggesting Truman was usurping Congress's ''lawmaking power."
The likely question for George W. Bush will be: Why not seek congressional approval for wiretapping terrorist suspects without judicial warrants? Given that so many other surveillance mechanisms were sweepingly approved by Congress in the 2001 Patriot Act, why not include warrant-free wiretaps?
comments powered by Disqus
- T. rex fossils arrive at Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History
- Quote of the Day -- Time Magazine's Top 100 People
- Investigation: The Resegregation of America's Schools
- 5 Explosive Revelations Leaked from Senate Report Exposing CIA Torture
- In Parts of the South, Glorifying Slavery No Longer Pays the Bills
- UC Berkeley professor emeritus Robert Harlan dies at 84
- She Came All the Way from Melbourne to Attend the OAH
- The 7 Most Popular HNN Videos from the 2014 OAH
- Jesse Lemisch’s up-from-below history is still strikingly original
- U.Va. Historian Alan Taylor Wins 2014 Pulitzer for Book on Slaves and War -- His second Pulitzer!