Arnold Beichman: Iraq's History of Falluja-Like Violence
Arnold Beichman, in the Washington Times (April 9, 2004):
The mutilation and gruesome display of four Americans in Fallujah, Iraq, last week raises a topic seldom openly discussed in the Middle East: the unusual kind of sadistic violence, historic in Iraq, reflecting the ethos of Iraqis when politically aroused.
What Iraqis in the street did to the Americans was copy what Saddam had been doing for years, by one form of torture or another, to the Iraqi people who accepted it as legitimate. In fact, Iraqi governance has for almost a half-century been based on the kind of violence that befell the American civilians. I will illustrate this anecdotally.
On a 1964 reporting tour of the Middle East, I entered Iraq. A year earlier, on Feb. 8, 1963, the military dictatorship of Abdel Karim Kassem, a general who had led the 1958 overthrow of the Western-allied Iraqi monarchy of King Feisal, was overthrown. Kassem was executed. His bloodied, uniformed corpse was sprawled over his office chair. Television cameras focused an entire day on the dead general as a still shot.
During my stay in Baghdad my wife and I were invited to an Egyptian Embassy party celebrating the country's independence day, There we met a charming English-speaking Iraqi diplomat and his American wife. They insisted we accompany them as their guests to an open-air Baghdad nightclub where we were entertained by a magician and Western dance music.
The next morning, I dropped into the U.S. Embassy for the pro forma briefing before embarking on my own interviews, I mentioned to the embassy officer how generously the Iraqi diplomat, head of the Foreign Ministry's protocol office, and his wife had entertained us. The embassy officer went to his office safe, twirled the knob, pulled out a folder, riffled through some 8x10 photos and tossed one at me with the question:
"Is that your protocol friend?"
It was, indeed, but in a rather frightening pose. After the overthrow July 14, 1958, of King Feisal, the king and his family and Prime Minister Nuri Pasha al-Said all were executed. But that wasn't enough. Their bodies then were tied to automobile rear bumpers and driven, auto horns blaring, through the streets of Baghdad.
And after that grisly tour through Baghdad streets, the mutilated corpses were hanged from a stretched steel cable for all to see. The photograph the U.S. Embassy officer produced showed my Iraqi protocolist bare-chested in shorts, with an eye-popping grin, pointing his forefinger at the dangling mangled cadavers. And then the embassy officer showed me the same photograph reduced to the size of tourist postcards which were sent around the Arab world with a legend in Arabic describing the photo....
... in the Middle East, no maxim has greater legitimacy than "the enemy of my enemy is my friend."
comments powered by Disqus
- David Rosand, an Art History Scholar Whose Heart Was in Venice, Dies at 75
- NYT interviews Rick Perlstein about his book
- OAH issues a statement in support of the AP standards
- Daniel Pipes says in interview that the absence of anti-Israel protests in Muslim countries is highly significant
- A historian who studies China has discovered an overlooked angle in the debate about the Middle East. Could he have figured out a key reason for Iraq’s failure to defeat ISIS?