Boston or Baghdad? Philadelphia or Fallujah?
[cross-posted at Austro-Athenian Empire]
I just saw Senator Lindsey Graham, as part of the televised post-mortem on Bushs blather, downplaying the lack of progress in Iraq by saying (wording not exact), Well, we had our revolution in 1776, and we didnt have a constitution until 1789.
Sorry, no. The United States first constitution was adopted provisionally in 1777, and formally ratified in 1781. What is conventionally called the U.S. Constitution was the second one.
(Im also not sure why Graham picked 1789 as the date of the (second) constitution. The minimum number of states needed for ratification of the second constitution was either nine (according to the second constitution) or all thirteen (according to the first); the former number was reached the year before 1789, and the latter the year after.)
And if Graham is suggesting that the level of civil chaos in Iraq today is comparable to that of the United States in the 1780s, I think the historians among us might venture a dissent.
I dont mean to suggest, of course, that 1780s U.S. was more peaceful and orderly than Iraq because it had a functioning constitution. On the contrary, the American colonies were pretty orderly during the complete suspension of governmental institutions, as Thomas Paine relates:
For upwards of two years from the commencement of the American War, and to a longer period in several of the American States, there were no established forms of government. The old governments had been abolished, and the country was too much occupied in defence to employ its attention in establishing new governments; yet during this interval order and harmony were preserved as inviolate as in any country in Europe. There is a natural aptness in man, and more so in society, because it embraces a greater variety of abilities and resource, to accommodate itself to whatever situation it is in. The instant formal government is abolished, society begins to act: a general association takes place, and common interest produces common security.
And Edmund Burke, Paines archenemy, confirms Paines point:
Pursuing the same plan of punishing by the denial of the exercise of government to still greater lengths, we wholly abrogated the ancient government of Massachusetts. We were confident that the first feeling, if not the very prospect, of anarchy would instantly enforce a complete submission. The experiment was tried. A new, strange, unexpected face of things appeared. Anarchy is found tolerable. A vast province has now subsisted, and subsisted in a considerable degree of health and vigor for near a twelvemonth, without Governor, without public Council, without judges, without executive magistrates. How long it will continue in this state, or what may arise out of this unheard-of situation, how can the wisest of us conjecture?
So the early United States didnt really need a constitution. But anyway, need one or not, they had one (and in many ways a better one than the second one). Senator Grahams strained analogy between Iraq and 1780s America wont work. (Maybe he should have tried a different tack: After our revolution we still had slavery ....)
comments powered by Disqus
Jason Pappas - 1/28/2007
Why do Americans see only mirror-images of themselves …
Do you not think there is such a thing as human nature and natural rights -- rights that universally apply to every individual? I thought that was the core of libertarianism.
Otto M. Kerner - 1/24/2007
What was that line from Full Metal Jacket? "Inside every gook there's an American trying to get out."
Sudha Shenoy - 1/24/2007
Why does Iraq have to be a carbon copy of the US? Why do Americans see only mirror-images of themselves every time they peer over the parapets of their, American, universe?
- Historian Fernando Prado on quest to find remains of Cervantes
- Historian shines a light on the dark heart of Australia's nationhood
- Female historian says human rights museum censored her
- Japanese historians slam sex-slave apology review
- Stephanie Coontz: "Marriages require much more maturity than they once did."