Manchuria and Iraq, 1932 and 2004
I sent a link to my recent HNN article along to the scholars on the H-Japan and H-Asia lists, suggesting it as a change of pace from the Vietnam analogies. Reponses have been appreciative, but, and this is what makes the technology so much fun, someone knew something I didn't and shared it, for which I am thankful. Michael Penn of the University of Kitakyushu wrote
You may be interested to know that the analogy between Iraq and Japanese Manchuria is much older than you suspect. On September 27, 1932, the Tokyo Asahi Shinbun wrote an editorial entitled"Iraku to Nichiman Kankei" (Iraq and Japanese-Manchurian Relations). The point they wanted to make was that Japan's activities in Manchuria were comparable to the British role in Iraq, and therefore Japan should not be criticized by the West.So I don't have to feel bad that (Pulitzer-prize winners) John Dower and Herbert Bix got there first: they were seventy years late, themselves!
I can easily imagine the Japanese in 1932 making the case that their activities in Manchuria were comparable to Britain's in Iraq: paternalistic developmentalism, resource stewardship, fighting anti-modern insurgencies. The League of Nations Mandate system sounded good, but it sounds like they were little more than dressed up colonialism. Japan certainly saw itself as acting in the same tradition that brought India under British control, turned Afghanistan into an imperial chessboard, chopped Africa into polyhedral shapes, brought China to its knees, and called it"modern progress." It was the hypocrisy of imperial powers condemning latecomers for imperialism that drove Japan and Italy out of the League of Nations; and the parallel between that and the hypocrisy of atomic weapons pioneer and unchallenged world leader USA condemning latecomers for"proliferating" is more than a little troubling.
We have got to be capable of better. Wouldn't it be easier to do the consistently right thing than to have to keep explaining ourselves, over and over and over?
comments powered by Disqus
- T. rex fossils arrive at Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History
- Quote of the Day -- Time Magazine's Top 100 People
- Investigation: The Resegregation of America's Schools
- 5 Explosive Revelations Leaked from Senate Report Exposing CIA Torture
- In Parts of the South, Glorifying Slavery No Longer Pays the Bills
- UC Berkeley professor emeritus Robert Harlan dies at 84
- She Came All the Way from Melbourne to Attend the OAH
- The 7 Most Popular HNN Videos from the 2014 OAH
- Jesse Lemisch’s up-from-below history is still strikingly original
- U.Va. Historian Alan Taylor Wins 2014 Pulitzer for Book on Slaves and War -- His second Pulitzer!