George Mason University's
History News Network

Entries by David Silbey


(View All Entries)

Cliopatria's History Blogroll Part I/Part II.
I’d like to thank Ralph Luker and the rest of the HNN folks for welcoming me to Cliopatria. Ralph’s introduced me pretty thoroughly, so I will spare everyone further self-aggrandizement and introduce the projects I’m bringing with me to Cliopatria.

The first, in conjunction with H-War, is the Military History Digest. This is a long-running series (the last edition was #144) which is, in essence, a roughly-biweekly digest of the best of the military history web, as chosen (egotistically) by me. I read quite a few military history blogs on a regular basis and I wanted to share the entries that I found particularly interesting. I am currently following 30 such blogs, and take from them what looks most interesting to include in the Digest. I’d love to add to my blog count, and welcome nominations in the comments from anyone with a good military history blog they think I should follow.

The second is the Military History Carnival, a regular digest of reader-nominated blog posts. This has fallen on hard times lately, lacking both hosts and nominations. I’d like to re-invigorate it; the military history blogosphere is wide and deep, and I think it should be able to sustain it. My aim at the moment is to start with a Carnival every three months. If that goes well, I will increase the frequency.

To that end, I’d like to announce, by way of closing this post, the nomination period for a new Military History Carnival. The Carnival itself will appear on February 26th, and the deadline will be two days before that, on February 24th. Nominations should be submitted here. I construe military history quite broadly to include not only battlefields and wars, but home-fronts and institutions, memory and memorialization, and everything in between. Anything published in the last three months is eligible.

Tuesday, January 25, 2011 - 18:08

It's interesting to note the way in which historical figures get trimmed and whittled into new shapes. Martin Luther King has become a figure of national memory, celebrated with an official holiday and, among other things, lots of streets. But in that process, much of King's more radical thoughts have been effectively sidelined. He has become a historical voice for justice, but justice of a particular kind. King's calls for economic justice have essentially disappeared, leaving behind his thoughts on civil rights. The de-radicalization allows King to be used by a broad range of people for a broad range of purposes, people who will not be made uncomfortable by the part of King's ideas that remain controversial.

Ronald Reagan, by contrast, is becoming somewhat re-radicalized."Ronaldus Magnus" has come to be an avatar to the American right.

This has led to the eliding of some of Reagan's actions, actions which do not fit well with current conservative orthodoxy. Thus, for example, Rush Limbaugh, confronted by a caller pointing out that Reagan raised taxes, could essentially refuse to believe him. The Reagan of today could not be seen to raise taxes, give amnesty to illegal immigrants, compromise with the Democrats, or negotiate with the Soviets. Thus, those aspects of his Presidency get written out. What is left is a saint for the right wing, updated for current positions. One who got a fair number of streets, also.

The point is to note the process in both cases. Historical figures get buffed and polished when they become part of the public memory, rough or uncomfortable edges sanded off. In a sense, those public memories begin to bear the same relationship to the actual person that war memorials bear to the actual wars. They stand for what the nation needs them to stand.


Tuesday, February 8, 2011 - 16:44

The Military History Digest is a long-running series which is, in essence, a roughly-biweekly digest of the best of the military history web, as chosen (egotistically) by me and organized by chronological topic. I read quite a few military history blogs on a regular basis and I share the entries that I find particularly interesting. Each entry has the post's title, author, and a snippet of the post itself. Nominations for new blogs to read are always welcome. Previous digests indexed here.

Contents

19th Century

1. Capturing the Horror of the Crater by Kevin Levin

Over the past few years I’ve seen a wide range of images of the battle of the Crater. Once I tidy up a few loose ends in my Crater manuscript I am going to turn to making a decision about illustrations for the book. I am planning to include images that give the reader a [...]...

2. Plans to Expand Vicksburg NMP by Craig Swain

H/t to CW Interactive’s Newswire: Plan would expand Vicksburg National Military Park An official press release from Senator Thad Cochran’s office reads: WASHINGTON, D.C. – U.S. Senator Thad Cochran (R-Miss.) today reintroduced his legislation to authorize the expansion of the … Continue reading →...

3. Slavery in the Provisional Confederate Constitution by Donald Shaffer

On February 8, 1861, the Montgomery Convention adopted a provisional constitution for their new nation. It would be in force for a little over a month before it was replaced by a more permanent document. As John J. Miller states in yesterday’s Disunion blog in the New York Times, the Provisional Confederate Constitution ”was more imitation than innovation” being heavily based on the U.S. Constitution. Yet in terms of slavery the Provisional Confederate Constitution was a significant departure. While slavery was present in both documents it was more implicit in the latter than the former. For instance, the word “slave...

4. A Debate Over the Black Confederate Debate by Brooks D. Simpson

Kevin Levin’s offered a thoughtful response to my post, “Seeing What is Not There.” Kevin concludes: What we have here is not a debate about whether free and enslaved blacks served as soldiers in the Confederate army. The folks referenced …

5. What’s Wrong With the Black Confederate Debate? by Kevin Levin

Brooks Simpson has chosen to wade into the mire that is the black Confederate “debate”. In his most recent post he surveys a short list of the standard primary sources that have been used to prove the existence of black men in the Confederate army. As Brooks notes, they are all problematic for any number [...]...

6. Disunion – White Union Soldiers and Emancipation by Donald Shaffer

Yesterday’s Disunion blog in the New York Times, written by Ronald Coddington, centers on the wartime experiences of Confederate Captain David Ramsey from Wilcox County, Alabama. This edition of Disunion would be of little interest to Civil War Emancipation except for an incident involving Ramsey related by Coddington. Having failed in their efforts to defend Island No. 10 on the Mississippi River against Union forces, Capt. Ramsey and his men found themselves prisoners-of-war. Coddington writes: The Alabamians spent that day in conversation with their captors. The federals “repelled as an insult the least insinuation that the war, professedly...

7. Katie Couric’s Notebook and Battlefield Preservation by Craig Swain

For the last few days I’ve mulled over one of Katie Couric’s Notebook entry from last week. In her opinion spot, the CBS news anchor noted the changed position with regard to Wal Mart’s proposed store near the Wilderness. “It’s been nearly 145 years since the end of the Civil War, and Walmart just surrendered.” [...]...

8. Gordon Rhea Article by Donald Shaffer

I hope Kevin Levin will excuse me if I piggyback on him again so quickly. I wouldn’t do it if he hadn’t shared an article yesterday highly relevant to Civil War Emancipation. I will say, as an aside, that I fully intend to do the same thing in the future under similar circumstances, giving full credit to the source, of course. So I’m in Kevin’s debt for sharing this article on Facebook. What Kevin shared was Gordon Rhea’s recent article in the Civil War Trust newsletter, entitled “Why Non-Slaveholding Southerners Fought.” Rhea provides a highly cogent explanation of why...

9. Kevin M. Weeks, Ann Dewitt, and Blacks “Serving” the Confederacy by Brooks D. Simpson

Kevin M. Weeks is the coauthor of a children’s book, Entangled in Freedom: A Civil War Story. As the website says: … this is an opportune time to discuss the views of your family or guardians as it relates to … Continue reading →...

10. Riddles and a Remote Fort – 42pdr Model 1839 by Craig Swain

The examination of the Model 1839 42-pdr Seacoast guns leaves me with several riddles to examine, but allows mention of a remote seacoast fortification. Earlier I introduced the four model numbers of the 42-pdr seacoast gun class in American service during the Civil War era. Although by regulation the class was declared obsolete at the [...]...

11. Big Flap Coming in Mississippi by The General

Mississippi looks to be the battleground over Civil War memory. The Sons of Confederate Veterans have decided to push their aggressive agenda by asking the State of Mississippi to offer a vanity license plate dedicated to Nathan Bedford Forrest. My thoughts on Forrest as a general are well known and need not be repeated here. Whether he was a good general is irrelevant to this discussion. What is relevant is that black soldiers were massacred by troops under his command at Fort Pillow and that Forrest was a Grand Wizard–and one of the founders–of the KKK. Those are...

World War I

1. Macaulay’s Prophetic Sterotypes by George Simmers

Rose Macaulay’s 1914 satirical novel, The Making of a Bigot pokes fun at many current intellectual fads, including the National Service League, which since 1902 had advocated vigorous preparation for war (Kipling was an active member). When a spokesman for the League gives a highly successful lecture at an East End Settlement, he invites his audience to a cinematograph display in Hackney the following week, called ” In Time of Invasion.” It was a splendid show, well worth three-pence. It abounded in men being found unlawfully with guns and being shot like rabbits; in untrained and incompetent soldiers fleeing from...

2. Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy and the Governance of Italy, 1861-1946 by Charles McCain

French Prime Minister George Clemenceau, British Premier David Lloyd-George and Italian Prime Minister Vittorio Emanuele Orlando at Paris Peace Conference in 1919. The Italians did not make a good impression during the treaty talks in Paris in 1919. Wrote Charles Seymour, a young staffer to the American delegation,"The Italians were very dramatic, waved their arms around, tears came into their eyes." On one occasion, while making Italy's case to the British, French, and Americans, Orlando...

World War II

1. Nazi Graphics Standards Manual by Jason Kottke

Steven Heller had heard rumors of a Nazi graphics standards manual for years and finally tracked one down. Published in 1936, The Organizationsbuch der NSDAP (with subsequent annual editions), detailed all aspects of party bureaucracy, typeset tightly in German Blackletter. What interested me, however, were the over 70 full-page, full-color plates (on heavy paper) that provide examples of virtually every Nazi flag, insignia, patterns for official Nazi Party office signs, special armbands for the Reichsparteitag (Reichs Party Day), and Honor Badges. The book"over-explains the obvious" and leaves no Nazi Party organization question, regardless of how minute...

2. Dwight D. Eisenhower: Carlo D'este and Geoffrey Perret by Pritzker Military Library

Authors Carlo D'Este and Geoffrey Perret visit the Library to discuss President Dwight D. Eisenhower, moderated by Lewis Sorely. Originally aired 10/24/03. ...

3. U-352 Dive Site by Charles McCain

Previously, I briefly mentioned the wreck of U-352 off the coast of North America in an introduction I did for Subsim.com about the persistence of U-Boat myths in the US. While mentioning the wreck, I did not delve into the life of U-352 at that time. U-352 was a Type VIIC U-Boat that was laid down on 11 March 1940, launched on 7 May 1941, commissioned on 28 August 1941, went on her first patrol on 15 January 1942, left for her second patrol on 7 April 1942, and was sunk on 9 May 1942...

4. A Psychiatrist on Combat Leadership in World War Ii's Tunisian Campaign by Thomas E. Ricks

What prevents combat trauma? In the same July 1944 article from the American Journal of Orthopsychiatry that I cited the other day, Dr. Herbert X. Spiegel, a psychiatrist assigned to an Army infantry battalion in North Africa in World War II, made these observations: Good leadership meant good morale, and this, in turn, meant a low psychiatric casualty rate and good performance...The company commander or platoon leader...saw to it that his men got the best possible food under the circumstances; sent blankets up to them at night if it were at all possible; made every effort to keep...

5. Japanese Ha-Go Tank Conservation – Part Two by John Kemister

Three months into this phase of the project has seen significant progress on both the external and internal conservation of the tank. Externally, all original armour plate components have been repaired. Replica plating has been fitted to replace inaccurate or missing components, with some plates requiring considerable modification to fit this individual tank, and to correct [...] ...

6. Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy and the Governance of Italy, 1861-1946 by Charles McCain

Island groups of the Aegean Sea. Benito Mussolini and Fascist blackshirts during the March on Rome in 1922. Benito Mussolini using the fascist salute during a speech in 1932. Italy wanted more than she received from the Paris Peace Conference. Much more. But there just wasn't enough jam to go around. Of colonies in Africa, none. Money? No. Something from Germany? Some ships perhaps? No. Nothing."You mean to say Mr. Big Three...

Cold War

1. Navy TV – USS Intrepid- the Legend and History by NavyTV

In commemoration of the Centennial of Naval Aviation kick-off event in San Diego this week, NavyTV has dug up from the archives a great video about the USS Intrepid (CV-11), the legendary aircraft carrier, which served this nation from WWII through the height of the Cold War. After being decommissioned in 1974, the Intrepid became [...]...

2. The BD Bookshelf: an Army Battalion Cut Off and Unsupported During Tet '68 by Thomas E. Ricks

What an interesting, thoughtful book. I've had this memoir, The Lost Battalion of Tet, on my shelf for a couple of years but had waited to read it in order of my research for the book I am working on. I am now, finally, studying the Vietnam War in 1968, so I turned to it. It is mainly about a 1st Air Cavalry infantry battalion that suffered 311 casualties in a few weeks, most of them after being surrounded outside Hue during the 1968 Tet Offensive, cut off with dwindling ammunition but without artillery support. First, it strikes me as...

Misc/Thematic

1. What Can Ike and Lawrence of Arabia Teach Us About Army Personnel Policy? by Thomas E. Ricks

By Crispin Burke Best Defense personnel policy bureau A recent Atlantic article by Tim Kane spotlights several top-performing officers who lament the military's peacetime personnel system, which promotes officers along a generic timeline. Many point to the promotion policies during the two World Wars, when innovative officers enjoyed meteoric advancement through the ranks. Anecdotes from the private sector and even the State Department suggest that many large, successful organizations promote leaders on a merit-based system, much as the US Army did during the World Wars. Nevertheless, every personnel system -- be it military, government, or private-sector -- is fraught...

2. Rumsfeld's Memoir: Was He the Most Destructive Secretary of Defense in U.S. History? - by Fred Kaplan - Slate Magazine by n/a

...

Thursday, February 10, 2011 - 17:48

If journalism is the first rough draft of history, then memoirs are perhaps a second draft, or a rebuttal of the first. In the latter category fits Donald Rumsfeld's newly published memoirs, Known Unknowns. Rumsfeld pulled the title from a press conference at which he waxed eloquent about knowledge. Hart Seely put Rumsfeld's ruminations into poetry form:
The Unknown
As we know,
There are known knowns.
There are things we know we know.
We also know
There are known unknowns.
That is to say
We know there are some things
We do not know.
But there are also unknown unknowns,
The ones we don't know
We don't know.

Controversial events or eras seem to spark waves of biographies, as the participants work furiously to justify their own actions. Post-World War I, British politicians and generals wrote a raft of histories and memoirs to explain and justify their actions. David Lloyd George's War Memories were just such a set of books, designed to"explain and vindicate" his actions in the First World War.[1] Winston Churchill was past master at such literary exercises, producing multi-volume works that laid out his roles in both world wars, albeit as histories of the wars, rather than simply memoirs. Perhaps Churchill's ego was too small to be contained by mere autobiography. As Arthur Balfour, a British politician of the time, wrote, The World Crisis, Churchill's account of the First World War was"autobiography, disguised as a history of the universe."[2] In that desire to vindicate comes an equal temptation to shape the events favorably, a desire that Rumsfeld seems not to have escaped, as Fred Kaplan points out at Slate:

Many autobiographies exhibit [the tendency to self-aggrandizement] to some extent. It can even be tolerable if it's joined to an engaging style or sage insights about broader matters. Rumsfeld's book has no such redeeming features. And even if it did, its distortions and lies (I use the term advisedly) are just too blatant to be countenanced.
Rebuttal, indeed.

[1] G.W. Egerton, “The Lloyd George” War Memoirs”: A Study in the Politics of Memory,” The Journal of Modern History 60, no. 1 (1988): 55-94.
[2] John Perry, Winston Churchill (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2010), 102.


Friday, February 11, 2011 - 11:07

The deadline for the next Military History Carnival is coming up next Thursday, February 24th. Submit your entries here

Contents

19th Century

1. Coming Attractions by Brooks D. Simpson

"As we approach the 202nd anniversary of the birth of Abraham Lincoln, I will return to continue and then to conclude the series on Lincoln’s comments on racial equality during the Lincoln-Douglas debates in an effort to set them in … Continue reading →..."

2. An Interesting Conundrum by The General

"This is one of those cases that ties up both my interest in Civil War history as well as my day job. Hat tip to Charlie Knight for bringing this to my attention. This article appeared in the February 11, 2011 edition of The Virginian-Pilot newspaper: Williamsburg collector will fight for Civil War sword Posted to: Military News Williamsburg – James City By Tim McGlone The Virginian-Pilot © February 11, 2011 NORFOLK Civil War artifacts collector Donald Tharpe paid $35,000 for a one-of-a-kind, Tiffany-made sword, and he’s not about to give it up easily..."

3. 42-Pdr Seacoast Models 1840 and 1845 by Craig Swain

"Thus far the story of the 42-pdr seacoast guns remains linear without many side threads. In summary after a departure from the caliber in the early days of the American republic, the Army returned to the 42-pdrs for seacoast defense … Continue reading →..."

4. Chauncey B. Van Deusen by Steve Soper

"Chauncey B. Van Deusen was born on April 17, 1838, in Horseheads, Chemung County, New York, the son of Walter (b. 1799) and Julia (Kent, b. 1800).New York native Walter married Julia in October of 1829, probably in New York. Chauncey’s family left New York and came to Kent County, Michigan with his parents in 1848, and by 1850 Chauncey was living with his family in Vergennes, Kent County where his father, who was blind, was working as a musician. By 1860 Chauncey was a farm laborer living with his family in Vergennes where his father owned a substantial..."

5. Appeasing Slaveholders: House Resolution of February 11, 1861 by Donald Shaffer

"On February 12, 1861, the Daily National Intelligencer reported on the activity of the U.S. House of Representatives the previous day. Like the Washington Convention meeting at Willard Hotel, the members of the House desperately wanted to preserve the Union. On that day, they debated measures that might accomplish that goal. Orris S. Ferry of Connecticut suggested a resolution to investigate the feasibility of a constitutional amendment mandating that a state could not secede without the approval of two-thirds of Congress, the President, and all the other states. “Resolved, That the Committee on the Judiciary be instructed to inquire..."

6. Waterloo Cross Stolen by n/a

"You may have already seen this news but the Hougoumont Cross which managed to survive the battle of Waterloo has been stolen, probably by someone who has let their enthusiasm for the Napoleonic period get out of hand...."

7. Who’s Afraid of Kevin Levin … and Why? | Crossroads by n/a

"..."

8. Destruction of USS Maine and the Rush Toward War by NHHC

"The Spanish-American War (21 April–13 August 1898) was a turning point in United States history, signaling the country’s emergence as a world power. The sinking of the battleship USS Maine in Havana Harbor on 15 February 1898 was a critical event on the road to that war. Many Cubans desired independence from Spain, and political [...]..."

9. Hmdb Civil War Updates – Week of February 14 by Craig Swain

"Post Valentine’s Day Civil War marker update. Twenty additions to the Civil War category at the Historical Marker Database this week as we continue through the winter slows. Entries from Georgia, Kansas, Missouri, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Wisconsin: - From Fitzgerald, Georgia a state marker notes the home of William Jordon Bush. Bush was the [...]..."

10. Who’s Afraid of Kevin Levin … and Why? by Brooks D. Simpson

"Over the past several years Kevin Levin’s blog, Civil War Memory, has become one of the most-consulted blogs in Civil War era history: it also enjoys a broader audience among historians and teachers of all stripes and a public interested … Continue reading →..."

11. Robert Clasby: Gettysburg by Pritzker Military Library

"Author Robert Clasby visits the Library to discuss his book: Gettysburg: You are There. Originally aired 10/23/03. ..."

12. Disunion: What Lincoln Meant to the Slaves by Donald Shaffer

"Yesterday’s Disunion blog in the New York Times has a piece by Steve Hahn, “What Lincoln Meant to the Slaves,” which provides a fine perspective on what the slaves were thinking and doing in the period leading up the Civil War. Hahn states, “Slaves’ response to the election of 1860 and their ideas about Lincoln’s intentions suggest that they, too, were important actors in the country’s drama of secession and war, and that they may have had an unappreciated influence on its outcome.“ Steve Hahn is one the best scholars of slavery and emancipation in the United States and his..."

13. What Lincoln Said at Charleston … in Context (Part Four) by Brooks D. Simpson

"Both Lincoln and Douglas reiterated their positions on slavery and race for the remaining two debates. In the sixth debate, held at Quincy on October 13, Lincoln set forth his position once more: It was in our first meeting, at … Continue reading →..."

14. Abraham Lincoln: Saint or Sinner? by Kevin Levin

"Sometimes I wonder if people are aware that there is a historical profession that has been engaged over the past few decades in the critical analysis of every aspect of Abraham Lincoln’s life. Consider the following description of an upcoming BBC documentary on Lincoln: To most Americans Abraham Lincoln is the nation’s greatest president – [...]..."

15. Black History Month Highlight: Robert Blake by matthew.t.eng@navy.mil (Matthew T. Eng)

"Contraband Robert Blake (Photo#: NH 103762)Robert Blake was born into slavery in Virginia. After escaping, he enlisted in the US Navy from Port Royal, Virginia and served on USS Marblehead during the Civil War. While off Legareville, Stono River, South Carolina, on 25 December 1863, Blake bravely served the rifle gun as Marblehead engaged Confederates on John's Island. The enemy eventually abandoned its position leaving munitions behind. For his bravery in this action, Blake was awarded the Medal of Honor.USS Marblehead engages a Confederate Battery on John's Island, Stono River, South Carolina, 25 December 1863 (Photo#: NH 79920)LCDR..."

16. Black History Month Spotlight: Civil War Moh Recipient Robert Blake by Civil War Navy

"Contraband Robert Blake (Photo#: NH 103762) Robert Blake was born into slavery in Virginia. After escaping, he enlisted in the US Navy from Port Royal, Virginia and served on USS Marblehead during the Civil War. While off Legareville, Stono River, South Carolina, on 25 December 1863, Blake bravely served the rifle gun as Marblehead [...]..."

World War I

1. For Valentine’s Day – the Airman Who Married the General’s Daughter by Nicholas Schmidt

"Recently, I have been working on the papers of Field Marshal the Lord Birdwood, the First World War British General who commanded the Australian Corps for much of the First World War (including at Gallipoli). Amongst the papers, donated by the Birdwood family in the 1960s, I have found a story I think is suitable [...] ..."

2. Book Review: Spies in Arabia by n/a

"Spies in Arabia: The Great War and the Cultural Foundations of Britain's Covert Empire in the Middle East by Priya Satia. Published by Oxford University Press, London. 472 pages, 2008. Reviewed by Commander Youssef Aboul-Enein, MSC, USN Stanford University Associate Professor Priya Satia has published an award winning book that pieces together the evolution of British intelligence in the Middle East. Those with an interest in intelligence networks and Middle East affairs will find this book worth reading. Special Duty Agents traveled under cover of the Palestine Exploration Fund before World War I, and British Royal Engineers traveled Egypt..."

World War II

1. Bomber Harris, Bomber Sceptic by Brett Holman

"One sub-species of military intellectual is the retired field marshal (or admiral, or air marshal) who, at the end of a long career, sets down their thoughts on the future of warfare for the interested reader. Even though they may be quite famous, their essays into futurism is nowadays read less often than that of their junior counterparts, full-time military intellectuals like J. F. C. Fuller or L. E. O. Charlton, who had substantial careers in the military but left while still relatively young (and may well have borne chips on their shoulders due to their usually enforced..."

2. German Light Cruiser Königsberg by Charles McCain

"I have written about the German light cruisers previously including the Königsberg. The Königsberg was the first of the three 'K' class light cruisers built and so they are also referred to as Königsberg class according to German naval tradition. The K class light cruisers suffered from many design problems since they were designed and built in the late 1920's and had to adhere to the strict limit's imposed on Germany by the Treaty of Versailles. As the design problems became increasingly apparent, the duties of the ships were limited to compensate and they increasingly failed to serve in..."

3. A World War Two Warship Sunk by a Nuclear Attack Submarine by Charles McCain

"During the Falklands War of 1982, the Argentinians invaded and took possession of the Falkland Islands. Although a territory of the British Crown since the 1830s, their sovereignty has been a matter of dispute for several centuries. In 1982, Argentina was in the midst of an economic crisis. At that time the country was ruled by a rather stupid military junta. Since they had no bread, the junta gave the Argentinian people a circus, which was the seizure of the Falklands. These islands have less than 3,000 people, the weather is foul on good days, and the only activity going..."

4. Preparing to Move: Reprimands, Promotions and Confessions by Carlie Walker

"Friday 14th February 1941 Pro pace [For peace]. Only Horan and Carroll at Mass. Lecture on Arabic – too hard for me. Tim and Owen here for lunch. Visited McCormack and Ronald. Hours too long at evening meets. Arthur Amies the only one working. Horan filling his torch. Saturday 15th February 1941 Finished the [...] ..."

5. Book Review: Churchill's Secret War by n/a

"Churchill's Secret War: The British Empire and the Ravaging of India during World War II by Madhusree Mukerjee. Published by Basic Books, a member of the Perseus Book Groups, New York. 319 pages, 2010. Reviewed by Commander Youssef Aboul-Enein, MSC, USN I have the great privilege to teach officers selected for the vital Afghanistan-Pakistan Fellows Program at the Industrial College of the Armed Forces in Washington D.C. These men and women spend a year totally immersed in the politics, culture, religions, and policies of Southwest Asia. One of my main challenges is to cultivate empathy and get students..."

6. Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy and the Governance of Italy, 1861-1946 by Charles McCain

"In order to truly get a grasp on why many respectable people supported Mussolini, and later Adolf Hitler, one has to understand the incredibly deep fear people who had any wealth at all had of Communism or what in that era they referred to as “Bolshevism.” If you take our fear of al-Qaeda, and magnify it fifty times, you will get a sense of what many people felt and not without..."

Cold War

1. Setting the Record Straight on Malayan Counterinsurgency Strategy by n/a

"Setting the Record Straight on Malayan Counterinsurgency Strategy: Interview with Karl Hack by Octavian Manea Download the Full Article: Setting the Record Straight on Malayan Counterinsurgency Strategy You are a long time researcher and observer of the Malayan Emergency. What were the core key ingredients that broke the back of the communist insurgents in the Malayan Emergency? The primary cause for putting the campaign on a firmly winning path? The game changer that helped at the end of the day to regain the initiative? That is a bit like asking, ‘In making a cup of tea, which action is the..."

2. From the Editor: the Navy Exchange, Hair Spray, Hsas, and Corruption by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"In the previous diary entry on 7 July, Clark wrote,"Believe it or not, hair oil is not available at the PX, and this has been a sore point with me. The PX has lots of female hair spray and lots of other ladies items even though there are only about 200 nurses in all of Vietnam. But they don’t have things like men’s hair oil."Clark was one of many contemporary observers who noticed that the Navy Exchange stocked quantities of women's items, like hair spray and cosmetics, that exceeded the 700 authorized females in South Vietnam. Clark does..."

3. Diary Entry 22: Saigon, Friday Night, 9 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Friday Night, 9 July 1965 Home late again as usual and dining tonight on cheese and crackers. Decided it would be a pleasant change from peanut butter.Started to write an entry last Wednesday night from an office out at Tan Son Nhut while I was waiting for a conference to start. After the first page was written, the conference got started and I haven’t stopped until now. After the conference on Wednesday night, we were up until early Thursday morning threshing out the plans. In the p.m. flew down to Vung Tau on business and got back here late..."

4. Diary Entry 23: Saigon, Saturday Night, 10 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Saturday Night, 10 July 1965 Another day gone by and I’m back in the BOQ for a rest, provided the phone does not ring tonight. Seems like it rings much too frequently at night these days. Seeing what is going on, it is going to be only a short time before the headquarters is going to commence around-the-clock operations. The way things are shaping up, that is the inevitable conclusion. So to avoid any embarrassment in the future, I intend to put my branch on a 24-hour footing beginning Monday. Probably won’t be very popular as..."

5. Naval Aviation Centennial: Neptune’s Atomic Trident (1950) by SteelJaw

"7 Feb 1950: In a demonstration of carrier long-range attack capabilities, a P2V-3C Neptune, with Commander Thomas Robinson in command, took off from Franklin D. Roosevelt off Jacksonville, Fla., and flew over Charleston, S.C., the Bahamas, the Panama Canal, up the coast of Central America and over Mexico to land next day at the Municipal Airport, San Francisco, Calif. The flight, which covered 5,060 miles in 25 hours, 59 minutes, was the longest ever made from a carrier deck. (Naval Aviation Chronology 1950-1953, Naval History Center) To set the scene – the immediate post-war environment called for..."

Misc/Thematic

1. The Four Chaplains: Famous for the Way They Died, Loved for the Way They Lived by The Bunny

"Four military chaplains mutually bound by the oath of office and a strong faith, Army Lts. George Fox, Alexander Goode, Clark Poling and John Washington had all met at the Army chaplain school, which was housed at Harvard University during World War II. Fox was a Methodist minister, Goode was a rabbi, Poling was a Catholic priest, and Washington was a Reformed Church of America minister. They were friends and were nicknamed “The God Squad.” By all accounts, they were well liked. All four of them were also on board the troop transport ship USAT Dorchester en route to various..."

2. Independent Duty Corpsmen by thomaslsnyder

"I had my introduction to Independent Duty Corpsmen when I served as Squadron Medical Officer in Destroyer Squadron Fifteen. Each ship in the squadron was served by one IDC and an assistant. I was the only physician for the six ships–usually steaming hundreds of miles from my position on the squadron flagship, so these men were the sole source of medical expertise for their crews. On one occasion, while the flagship was involved in an underway replenishment (during which, the ship, sailing a parallel course with a supply vessel while supplies–food, shells for the big guns, even fuel..."

3. Black History Month Highlight: William Tillman by matthew.t.eng@navy.mil (Matthew T. Eng)

"The Attack on the Second Mate." NHHC PhotographThe National and Department of Defense theme for this year's observance is"African Americans and the Civil War." In honor of this year's theme and every African American past and present in the United States Navy, we will be highlighting several African Americans who served during the American Civil War. Today, we will be highlighting civilian ship's cook William Tillman (also spelled William Tilghman).This brief biography of William Tillman's courageous actions during the Civil War are reprinted here, courtesy of the Naval History and Heritage Command.William Tilghman was serving as cook on..."

4. Hms Caroline by noreply@blogger.com (Robert Farley)

"This is troubling:HMS Caroline is a light cruiser, a greyhound of the seas. Built in 1914, she served throughout the First and Second World Wars. She is the last survivor of the Battle of Jutland, and the last major ship to survive from the Grand Fleet. To stand on her bridge, with her tripod mast towering above you, is an unforgettable experience; and it is equally extraordinary to explore her galley, fitted out in 1914, or to sit in the doctor’s surgery, or to walk into her steering flat. She has the only in situ First World War turbines in..."

5. A Four Star Blog Post X 2: Lessons Learned From Our Carrier Tours by Adm Harvey and Adm Stavridis by admin

"Introduction When I graduated from the Naval Academy in 1991 and prepared to embark on my career as a Surface Warfare Officer, I asked my father, a retired SWO, if he had any advice. Drawing from his 30 years of experience, he provided me only these simple words, “Don’t hit the Bird Farm.” It sounded simple enough. In the past 20 years, there have been many occasions in which those words have come to mind. I have not served aboard an aircraft carrier and there have only been a handful of occasions in which I have been aboard one of..."


Friday, February 18, 2011 - 14:13

And if you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you:
In George Washington’s case, there was actually a public referendum on whether to call the George Washington Bridge the George Washington Bridge. And George Washington actually lost.

In a display of enormous practicality, the winning name was the"Hudson River Bridge" which, though it lacked poetry, did have the definite advantage that everyone would have known exactly which body of water the bridge crossed. The Port Authority promptly ignored the results of its own referendum and the George Washington Bridge it became.

(H/T to the New York Times)


Saturday, February 19, 2011 - 12:33

The next Military History Carnival (#26) is coming this Monday.

Contents

19th Century

1. A Fugitive Slave Wins His Freedom by Donald Shaffer

"February 18, 1861 is generally remembered as the day Jefferson Davis took his oath as Provisional President of the Confederacy (read Adam Goodheart’s fascinating analysis of Davis’ inaugural speech in Disunion). But also on that day a brief story appeared in the New York Times, with the headline “Decision in the case of the Fugitive Slave Anderson.; THE PRISONER SET AT LIBERTY.“ The story read: HAMILTON, C.W., Saturday, Feb. 16. The final decision in the case of ANDERSON, the fugitive slave, was given to-day. The Court sustained the decision of the Court of Queen’s Bench on the question of..."

2. Sons of Confederate Veterans Forced to the Back of the Bus by Kevin Levin

"Even in the “Heart of Dixie” the Sons of Confederate Veterans can muster little more than a few hundred people from its ranks to commemorate the inauguration of Jefferson Davis. Based on the YouTube clip below yesterday’s event sounded more like a political rally than a reenactment. The speaker’s comparison of the SCV’s challenges with [...]..."

3. Edward Van Wert by Steve Soper

"Edward Van Wert was born on November 19, 1839, in Groveland, Livingston County, New York, the son of Isaac (d. 1812) and Jemima Ann (Groesbeck, 1815-1844/48).Isaac and Jemima were both born in Renssalear County, New York and were married at the bride’s home in New York in September of 1832. By 1844 the family had settled in Washtenaw County, Michigan where Jemima died in November of that year. According one report soon after the death of his wife Isaac left his children with relatives in Tyrone, Kent County, probably until the following year when he remarried a..."

4. William Van Dyke by Steve Soper

"William Van Dyke was born on April 14, 1843, in Monroe County, Michigan, the son of Henry (1802-1855) and Eliza (b. 1805). By 1860 Irish-born Eliza had moved her son to the western side of the state and William was a student living with his mother, working as a domestic (but with some $2000 dollars in personal property) possibly with the Barringer family in Crockery, Ottawa County.William was 18 years old and probably living in Crockery or Kent County when he enlisted with his mother’s’ consent in Company C on May 13, 1861.On April 6, 1863..."

5. SCV and Earl Ijames Do Better by Kevin Levin

"Tony Way of the SCV and Earl Ijames are working to commemorate ten black North Carolinians, nine of which have been identified as slaves, who were present in the Army of Northern Virginia as slaves. This is truly a step in the right direction given the way this story was reported back in May 2010. [...]..."

6. Should Nathan Bedford Forrest Be on a License Plate? by Brooks D. Simpson

"Word comes from various sources, including Eric Wittenberg’s Rantings of a Civil War Historian and local press coverage, of efforts by the Mississippi chapter of the Sons of Confederate Veterans to propose several new special vanity plate designs, including one … Continue reading →..."

7. Dr. Thomas P. Lowry Responds | Crossroads by n/a

"..."

8. A Northern Religious Perspective on Slavery by Donald Shaffer

"February 24, 1861 was a Sunday. No doubt, many Americans, South and North, attended religious services that day. One such group of the faithful gathered that February 24 at the Congregational Church in Norfolk, Connecticut, to hear the sermon of the Reverend Joseph Eldridge. Eldridge’s talk that day was titled ”Does the Bible Sanction Slavery?” It so impressed his parishioners that they petitioned him to publish it which he did. Civil War Emancipation already has covered two pro-slavery sermons, one from Louisiana and the other from Georgia. So, both for some sectional balance and because the sermon was delivered..."

9. Dr. Thomas P. Lowry Responds by Brooks D. Simpson

"It’s been exactly a month since the National Archives announced that Thomas P. Lowry had confessed to altering the date on a Lincoln document so as to make it appear that the president signed the document on April 14, 1865, … Continue reading →..."

10. Cw 150 Legacy Project: Virginia Memory Scanning Project by matthew.t.eng@navy.mil (Matthew T. Eng)

"It seems that victories, albeit tiny in comparison to the grand spectacle of the war itself, continue to surface during the sesquicentennial years. Documents, once privately-held, are continuously There was a recent post on the Virginia Civil War Sesquicentennial Commission's Facebook page about an ongoing project conducted by the Library of Virginia and the Virginia Civil War Sesquicentennial Commission. The article, appearing on progress-index, talks about two members of the Legacy Project scanning documents in Dinwiddie found by a woman who decided to save them from a soon to be demolished house in Sussex County. As with all..."

11. The Fine Craftsmanship of the Revere Copper Napoleon Guns by Craig Swain

"Federal production 12-pdr Model 1857 “Light” Field Guns are one of, if not THE, largest group of surviving field pieces from the Civil War. These came from five vendors – Cyrus Alger, Ames Manufacturing, Miles Greenwood (Eagle Iron Works), Henry … Continue reading →..."

World War I

1. World War One Navy Recruiting Posters by Charles McCain

"A constant theme throughout the history of the United States is the need for manpower for the armed services. To this end, there have always been recruiting efforts and the most simple and straight forward of these has been the poster. No matter which era they are from, they repeat a common message - do your duty and serve your country because only through your help can we win. Over the next few weeks, I will be providing some examples of these recruiting posters as they pertain to the Navy. The following posters are all from World War One and carry..."

2. German Light Cruiser Königsberg by Charles McCain

"I have written about the German light cruisers previously including the Königsberg. The Königsberg was the first of the three 'K' class light cruisers built and so they are also referred to as Königsberg class according to German naval tradition. The K class light cruisers suffered from many design problems since they were designed and built in the late 1920's and had to adhere to the strict limit's imposed on Germany by the Treaty of Versailles. As the design problems became increasingly apparent, the duties of the ships were limited to compensate and they increasingly failed to serve in..."

3. World War One Treasure Trove Found by Peter Burness

"Vignacourt is an old rural village in France, larger than most, 12 kilometres north of the city of Amiens. During the First World War it stood behind the front-line of the Somme fighting, although the action was never far away and soldiers were always present. For much of the time it was a forward rest [...] ..."

4. German Light Cruiser Königsberg by Charles McCain

"I have written about the German light cruisers previously including the Königsberg. The Königsberg was the first of the three 'K' class light cruisers built and so they are also referred to as Königsberg class according to German naval tradition. The K class light cruisers suffered from many design problems since they were designed and built in the late 1920's and had to adhere to the strict limit's imposed on Germany by the Treaty of Versailles. As the design problems became increasingly apparent, the duties of the ships were limited to compensate and they increasingly failed to serve in..."

5. The Last Veteran? by light.sue@gmail.com (Sue Light)

"There has been a fair bit of publicity this week for Florence Green, who on reaching her 110th birthday has been named as both a 'super-centenarian' and also the last surviving female 'veteran' of the Great War. As time goes by, the definition of 'last veteran' seems to have changed. Once it was used solely for those men who had met the Germans or other adversaries on the battlefield, but as they disappeared, it was broadened to include anyone who was in military service at any time during the Great War. Florence Green joined the Women's Royal Air Force..."

World War II

1. A Pro-Nazi U.S. Army Unit in WWII by Thomas E. Ricks

"Yep. Gather round, little grasshoppers, and I will tell the strange tale. I know it sounds like the reverse of a Quentin Taratino movie, but it is true: During World War II, the Army intentionally formed a unit chockablock with fascisti and their suspected sympathizers. What a sensible idea -- much better than kicking them out into society and losing track of them. This is all discussed in the new issue of Army Lawyer , where Fred Three Sticks Borch has a fascinating article about PFC Dale Maple, a brilliant young man who was born in San Diego in 1920 and who..."

2. Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy and the Governance of Italy, 1861-1946 by Charles McCain

"Mussolini was not the buffoonish clown he seems today. He was quite deadly and quite serious and was very much a dictator. In fact, the first dictator in the 20th Century in the West, a pioneer as it were. At first he was popular but after a few years the economy got worse and he grew deeply unpopular and would have been voted out of office. Benito Mussolini gives a speech to the..."

3. Lockheed Hudson – More Holes by Jamie Croker

"A second large hole has been cut into the fuselage this week, this being for the lower tunnel gun position. A large amount of modification to the airframe had been carried out to support flooring, and various large camera mounts thorughout it’s time as a geo survey platform. All these modifications were removed to clear the [...] ..."

Cold War

1. Diary Entry 29: Saigon, Saturday Night, 17 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Saturday Night, 17 July 1965 The Big Red One (1st Infantry Division, 2nd Brigade) has landed. That was the purpose of part of my trip last month to Vung Tau, Cam Ranh Bay, Qui Nhon, and elsewhere. We had to figure out where best to stage them through which ports and airfields. Finally settled on Cam Ranh Bay for 1/3, stage the balance off ships to shore at Vung Tau then by air to Bien Hoa air base. Moved 3,500 or so without so much as a small injury to any. Came off well. When the actual move..."

2. Diary Entry 27: Saigon, Thursday Night, 15 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Thursday Night, 15 July 1965 Went to Vung Tau Monday to watch landings by the 2nd Brigade, 1st Infantry Division, at that station. Can say what unit it is now that they have come ashore. They could not get ashore from the boats due to high seas so we let them stay on board over night. There wasn’t that much business that day and came back to Saigon. At any rate, went back the next day---now remember it was Tuesday and we had another bad day. Finally got them in on Wednesday (9:00 a.m. at least) and..."

3. Diary Entry 25: Saigon, Sunday Night, 11 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Sunday Night, 11 July 1965Feel pretty pleased with myself tonight. Worked real hard all day and got caught up with that infernal paperwork. Feel like I can breathe again with all of it out of the way for a day or two. Grady moved today so it is kinda quiet here tonight. He came by to tell me his room at the Vinh Loi is not as nice as this apartment, but he expects to move up to better things as others move out. No more guns around here to scare me. Woke up this morning at 4:30..."

4. Diary Entry 31: Saigon, Tuesday, 20 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Tuesday, 20 July 1965Today is the Vietnamese Independence Day and all US forces have been restricted to work areas or BOQs. The South Vietnamese had a big rally this morning against the Communists and there was a possibility that the rally could have turned into a riot. Tonight they expect some counter-action from the VC in the form of incidents against Americans, so we are all buttoned up. Don’t think you could find an American out on the street tonight if you tried.Had an unusual experience today. This morning I sat at a desk which had the nameplate..."

5. Diary Entry 30: Saigon, Monday Night, 19 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Monday Night, 19 July 1965Today I feel kinda blown up and want to brag. This afternoon briefed one of Mr. McNamara’s “whiz kids”---one of the assistant secretaries of Defense---and came out a winner. [Clark probably briefed Paul R. Ignatius, who served as the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Installations and Logistics in July 1965.] He had given all previous briefers a hard time because they did not have answers but I didn’t miss a one. Later in the day, he came down to our office and said to me, “Well, I see that transportation at least is..."

Post-Cold-War

1. Harriers From Nassau by NHHC

"On 20 February 1991 the amphibious assault ship USS Nassau (LHA4) launched four AV-8B Harriers of Marine Attack Squadron (VMA) 331, flight call sign ‘Magic’ just before dawn. This flight was the first combat strike by fixed-wing aircraft from the flight deck of an amphibious assault ship, and was directed at Iraqi anti-aircraft batteries and [...]..."

Misc/Thematic

1. War Is Cute by Brett Holman

"I've previously posted some of Gorden Cullen's artwork for the Tecton Group's 1939 book Planned A.R.P.. Here are some more of his cute drawings dealing with an awful subject. In this case, he is illustrating the 'general agreement among experts' on the threat posed by the bomber. (a) The range, speed, and carrying capacity of bombers have increased enormously since the last war.1 This was a commonplace observation and was demonstrably true, as anyone who knew anything at all about aviation would know. (b) In order to avoid anti-aircraft fire, balloon barrages, etc., the attacking bombers will probably..."

2. Navy TV – the Story of the Pea Island Lifesavers by NavyTV

"Watch the story of the legendary Pea Island Life Savers, an all-black lifesaving crew that accomplished one of the most daring rescues in the annals of the Life Saving Service in 1896, saving the entire crew of the three-masted schooner E.S. Newman, for which they were posthumously awarded the Gold Lifesaving Medal by the Coast [...]..."

3. History in Fiction by George Simmers

"There are two articles in today’s Guardian about the use of history in fiction. Helen Dunmore’s piece begins like this: A novelist who uses historical material in fiction has to go beyond the black and white, beyond the received images which are so familiar that our eyes are dulled to them, beyond the speeches and public cheering faces, and into the colour, intimacy and resonance of being alive at that time, not knowing what is to come, unaware of one’s place in history, of analyses that will be made or outcomes that will be debated. This made me chortle more..."

4. Rifled 42-Pounders – the Federal Side by Craig Swain

"As mentioned in earlier posts about the 42-pdr seacoast guns, the history of the type begins to thread out a bit after production of the Model 1845. Concurrent with the start of the Civil War, technical advances rendered the 42-pdr … Continue reading →..."


Friday, February 25, 2011 - 15:58

Welcome to the February 27, 2011 edition of the military history carnival. The Military History Carnival has had something of a nomadic life, and I'm aiming (with much thanks to HNN) to give it a more permanent home at Cliopatria, publishing one every three months. There's certainly space within that for other folks to host an MHC, if they're interested. In any case, today's Carnival, #26, has a good number of submissions for your perusal, organized topically

American Civil War

Nesher presents Girl Impregnated by the Bullet (Civil War Legend) posted at Best Hoaxes and Pranks.

Jonathan Beard presents the Civil War Reconstructed at the Wall Street Journal

World War I Era

Jonathan Beard submits Save HMS Caroline: The Last Survivor of the Battle of Jutland at Military Times

World War II Era

Alan Baumler submits the history of a double murder in Japan during the American occupation at Frog in a Well

Thematic

Romeo Vitelli presents Soldier's Disease (Part 1) posted at Providentia, saying,"Did the U.S. Civil War lead to thousands of morphine addicts?"

Vietnam

J.R. Clark presents A Vietnam War Clerk's Diary: INTRODUCTION: Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, 15 June 1962 posted at A Vietnam War Clerk's Diary.

Second Gulf War

Asad presents Timeline: Invasion, surge and withdrawal in Iraq posted at Modern Marine Corps.

Katie Sorene presents 7 Most Fascinating Asian Battle Sites posted at Travel Blog - Tripbase, saying,"A selection of fascinating Asian battle-sites for the historically minded traveler including the ancient temples of Angkor, the highlands of Laos and the inexplicable atrocity that was Hiroshima."

That concludes this edition. The next Military History Carnival will be May 27th at HNN. Submit your blog article for that edition by May 24th using our carnival submission form. Past posts and future hosts can be found on our blog carnival index page.


Monday, February 28, 2011 - 09:49

Contents

Early Modern

1. Extra! US Marines in Tripoli by Charles McCain
"Wow. US Marines in Tripoli. Who would have thought? But I don’t mean the Marines are in Tripoli or Libya now. They were there in 1804. Why? An American frigate, USS Philadelphia, had been captured by the Barbary Pirates and brought into Tripoli harbor, which the pirates controlled. In February of 1804, a band of American sailors and US Marines, led by Lieutenant Stephen Decatur, USN, made a daring night raid and set the USS Philadelphia afire which destroyed the ship. Thus the line in the Marine Hymn “…to the shores of Tripoli."

19th Century

1. Black History Month Highlight: Aaron Anderson by matthew.t.eng@navy.mil (Matthew T. Eng)
"Aaron Anderson served on USS Wyandank during the Civil War. While part of a boat crew clearing Mattox Creek, Virginia on 17 March 1865, Anderson performed his duties in the face of devasting enemy fire. For his courage during this action, he was awarded the Medal of Honor.According to the 18 March 1865 account included in the Official Records, Anderson recieved special notice of his courage during the boat expedition. According to T.H. Eastman, commanding USS Don,"the crew of th eboat were all black but two," further adding that a white boatswain's mate and Aaron Anderson were specifically"reported..."

2. How Should We as a Nation Mark the 150th Anniversary of the Civil War? by kientzla@msu.edu (Lauren Kientz Anderson)

No summary available

3. Lincoln and Colonization Revisited by Brooks D. Simpson
"There has been some buzz lately about a new book that takes yet another look at Abraham Lincoln’s continuing interest in “colonization,” meaning the relocation of African Americans outside the United States. Contrary to what is sometimes asserted, historians have"

4. Debating Dilorenzo: Lincoln, Secession, and Sumter by Brooks D. Simpson
"Here’s what Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo told Brian Lamb in 2008 about Lincoln, secession, and the Sumter crisis: LAMB: … I want to ask you something you said. Was he a great man? DILORENZO: He was – when you consider that …"

5. Debating Dilorenzo: a Lincoln Above Criticism? by Brooks D. Simpson

"To date I’ve discussed several statements made by Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo in a 2008 interview with Brian Lamb on C-SPAN. To me, one of the most interesting characteristics of the interview is that both Lamb and DiLorenzo strayed often from … Continue reading →..."

6. Learning From History … or Not? by Brooks D. Simpson

"Why didn’t South Carolina think of this in 1861? Oh, that’s right … it had agreed to the federal government’s taking the land upon which it built Fort Sumter. Never mind...."

7. Debating Dilorenzo: on Cultism as a Career by Brooks D. Simpson

"In the exchange that follows, Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo explains to Brian Lamb what he believes motivates members of what he defines as a Lincoln “cult”: LAMB: What do you think is driving most of the, and there depending on what … Continue reading →..."

8. Debating Dilorenzo: Three Lincoln Cultists by Brooks D. Simpson

"Returning once more to Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo’s 2008 interview with Brian Lamb on C-SPAN …here’s Dr. DiLorenzo on what he calls the Lincoln “cult”: LAMB: If you could get everybody that you call the Lincoln cultists or people who are … Continue reading →..."

9. Debating Dilorenzo: Court Historians by Brooks D. Simpson

"In 2008 Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo explained to Brian Lamb what he meant by the term “court historian”: LAMB: I want to break down the first sentence a little bit more, what’s a ”museum quality specimen court historian” you write about … Continue reading →..."

10. Debating Dilorenzo: Distortion and Dismissal by Brooks D. Simpson

"In what must rank as one of the more interesting parts of Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo’s interview with Brian Lamb in 2008, we learn of a supposed conspiracy of Lincoln scholars to embarrass him through the History Channel: LAMB: Have you … Continue reading →..."

11. Bands on the Guns: Southern Rifled-Banded 42pdrs by Craig Swain

"Normally I start out discussing the background, manufacture, and history of a particular cannon type, and offer one of my charts to back up the particulars. In this case, let me start out with some photos to establish the presence … Continue reading →..."

12. Slavery in Lincoln’s First Inaugural Address by Donald Shaffer

"On March 4, 1861, Abraham Lincoln at last took the oath as the 16th President of the United States. His first inaugural address has received much analysis over the years. Disunion in the New York Times added to the list yesterday by commissioning essays on the topic by four more scholars. Civil War Emancipation will append a bit more by analyzing Lincoln’s first inaugural as it pertains to slavery. Slavery is the major subject in Lincoln’s inaugural speech because at the heart of his address was the sectional crisis and slavery was at the heart of the sectional crisis. Lincoln..."

13. Ervin Jordan’s Black Confederates by Kevin Levin

"Spend enough time in the confusion that is the black Confederate debate and you will come across a short list of talking points. One of the most popular references is to Ervin L. Jordan’s Black Confederates and Afro-Yankees in Civil War Virginia (A Nation Divided : New Studies in Civil War History), which was published [...]..."

14. African Americans in the Union Navy: Honor, Courage, Commitment by matthew.t.eng@navy.mil (Matthew T. Eng)

"Crewmembers cooking on deck, in the James River, Virginia, 9 July 1862. Photographed by James F. Gibson. The contraband sailor in the foreground of the image is Siah Carter. A Call to Arms USS Miami, 1864-1865The enlistment of African Americans changed the makeup of the Union Navy, even if it often split public opinion. Any attempt to block African Americans from entering the service were halted during the war, allowing them to swell the ranks. One estimate placed roughly 16% of the total enlisted force as black. Rather than restrict black enlisted men to special units, historian James Harrod..."

15. Untying the Gordian Knot by The General

"I am in the midst of doing an overhaul of my 2002 book Protecting the Flank: The Battles for Brinkerhoff’s Ridge and East Cavalry Field, Battle of Gettysburg, July 2-3, 1863. This is one of my favorite titles of my work, even though it’s a short book. It was the first in Ironclad’s The Discovering Civil War America Series–an idea I came up with–and it also made the most extensive use of The Batchelder Papers of any study of East Cavalry Field yet published. It has also sold steadily over the years, and I am grateful to..."

16. Stephen Mallory - Secretary, Confederate States of America by yelpmark@comcast.net (Seaman Rob)

"On March 4, 1861, Stephen R. Mallory was appointed Secretary of the Navy of the Confederate States of America. To me, he is one of the more interesting persons of the Civil War navies, Union or Confederate. Born circa 1813 in Trinidad, he was raised mostly in Key West, Florida. He began his professional career in the early 1800’s practicing maritime law in the Florida Keys (at the time a hot bed of “wrecking” – the recovery of cargo from ships wrecked on the reefs of the Keys). Eventually he went into politics, representing Florida in the U.S. Senate. There..."

World War I

1. Researching Armies of the Adowa Campaign, Part 1: Ethiopia by n/a

"Guest Author; Sean McLachlan talks about reseraching his new Men-at-Arms in the first of a two part series on Italy's greatest colonial disaster...."

2. World War One Navy Recruiting Posters by Charles McCain

"A constant theme throughout the history of the United States is the need for manpower for the armed services. To this end, there have always been recruiting efforts and the most simple and straight forward of these has been the poster. No matter which era they are from, they repeat a common message - do your duty and serve your country because only through your help can we win. Over the next few weeks, I will be providing some examples of these recruiting posters as they pertain to the Navy. The following posters are all from World War One and carry..."

3. Rudyard Kipling: 'the Changelings' by noreply@blogger.com (Tim Kendall)

"Rudyard Kipling, let it be said again, is the finest short story writer in English. At least, I haven't read a better. Much as I adore the plotted viciousness of The Jungle Books, my favourite collection is Debits and Credits (1926), which comes late enough in Kipling's career to be classified as---in Edmund Wilson's pointed phrase---'the Kipling that nobody read'. Although the book contains several masterpieces which regularly appear in selections from Kipling's work (most notably, 'The Wish House', 'The Bull that Thought', 'The Eye of Allah'), it has fallen out of print for long periods. The neglect..."

World War II

1. Iwo Jima by Steven Terjeson

"On of the bloodiest battles to occur during the entirety of World War II happened on a small desolate island in the vast Pacific (16 Feb 1945 – 26 Mar 1945). American Flag on Iwo Jima overlooking the landing beaches.“Iwo Jima, which means sulfur island, was strategically important as an air base for fighter escorts supporting long-range bombing missions against mainland Japan. Because of the distance between mainland Japan and U.S. bases in the Mariana Islands, the capture of Iwo Jima would provide an emergency landing strip for crippled B-29s returning from bombing runs. The seizure of Iwo..."

2. Gen. Ridgway on Combat, Man, and the Extraordinary Flaws of Gen. Macarthur by Thomas E. Ricks

"I find Gen. Matthew Ridgway, who commanded the 82nd Airborne in World War II and turned around the Korean War in early 1951 after MacArthur screwed it up, endlessly interesting. When I was up at the Army Military History Institute in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, doing book research last month, I spent a day reading his oral history interviews, some of them corrected in his own hand, and signed by him at the end in the same ink. Here are some of my favorite passages: On the strains of combat: The best of troops will fail if the strain is big enough..."

3. Casual Fridays by Jason Sigger

"Apologies as to the lateness of today's Casual Fridays post. It's been one of those weeks. I had finished this book last week, and really wanted to say a few words about it. Fast Tanks and Heavy Bombers is about a particularly interesting and pivotal periods of the US Army's growth, 1917-1945 (as it says on the cover). General John Black Jack Pershing is famous for saying that the three big innovations of World War I was the tank, the airplane, and poison gas. It's unfortunate that the authors had left off the growth of the US Army Chemical..."

4. The National Government and the Air by Brett Holman

"A while back, The National Archives made all Cabinet papers from 1915 to 1980 freely available for download. Now TNA Labs have created a visualisation tool for said papers, allowing you to see clouds of the 25 most frequent words and contributors for any year (month in wartime) or, using the 'flexible querying' mode, any period you specify (up to ten years). Mouse-overing each result gives the actual count and links to the relevant DocumentsOnline entries. It's something of a toy at the moment (though they encourage you to download the XML dataset it is based upon and play..."

5. Researching Armies of the Adowa Campaign, Part 1: Ethiopia by n/a

"Guest Author; Sean McLachlan talks about reseraching his new Men-at-Arms in the first of a two part series on Italy's greatest colonial disaster...."

6. The Most Experienced U-Boat Builders in the World: Howaldtswerke-Deutsche Werft and the German Type 212A U-Boat (1 of 4) by Charles McCain

"The Type 212A U-Boat is the latest submarine built by Germany and is the most advanced non-nuclear type in the world. It was designed and built by a long time supplier of U-Boats to the German Navy, Howaldtswerke-Deutsche Werft in Kiel. On their company website, HDW proclaims:"Virtually no shipyard the world over has more experience in the design and construction of non-nuclear submarines." I guess not. During World War Two, the Deutsche Werft shipyard in Kiel built 69 U-Boats for the Kriegsmarine while Howaldtswerke yard in Kiel built 31 U-Boats. (Both shipbuilders..."

7. German Light Cruiser Königsberg by Charles McCain

"I have written about the German light cruisers previously including the Königsberg. The Königsberg was the first of the three 'K' class light cruisers built and so they are also referred to as Königsberg class according to naval tradition. The K class light cruisers suffered from many design problems since they were designed and built in the late 1920's and had to adhere to the strict limit's imposed on Germany by the Treaty of Versailles. As the design problems became increasingly apparent, the duties of the ships were limited to compensate and they increasingly failed to serve in the..."

8. Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy and the Governance of Italy, 1861-1946 by Charles McCain

"When last we left the evil twins, Mussolini and King Victor Emmanuel III, World War Two had broken out. The Germans attacked Poland and the Italians, well, they hesitated, saying their alliance with Germany was"defensive." Hitler was furious. At least this showed some thinking going on at the top of the Italian Government. Or maybe just inertia since the King himself didn't seem to do much thinking."

9. A Profile in Courage—Petty Officer George E. Whalen by NHHC

"On the island of Iwo Jima on 26 February 1945, Pharmacist’s Mate Second Class George E. Whalen, USNR, attached to a rifle company in the Second Battalion, 26th Marines, retrieves a wounded Marine from in front of his company’s lines and carries him to safety. He is wounded in the left eye before he accomplishes [...]..."

10. Hospital Ship “Op Ten Noort” by thomaslsnyder

"by Thomas L Snyder This past weekend (27 Feb-1Mar) marked the 69th anniversary of the Battle of the Java Sea, in which a combined American-British-Dutch-Australian fleet was completely destroyed by an equal-sized Japanese fleet which enjoyed the advantages of superior gunnery, air superiority and a new, long-range torpedo. Only one hospital ship was present in the area, Op ten Noort.(1) Launched in Amsterdam in 1927, she was originally commissioned to passenger service in the Dutch East Indies, now Indonesia. With the onset of World War II, the Dutch Royal Navy took her up..."

Cold War

1. Algeria, the Assassination of Charles De Gaulle, and the Day of the Jackal (Part 1 of 2) by Charles McCain

"Algiers. Algeria. Bombing. Mayhem. Riot. Protest. If you have wondered, like me, what exactly the phrase, “the past is prologue” means, then look no further than Algeria now, for violence and mayhem have a long history in that country. Though long forgotten, France had a large colonial empire which included modern day Algeria. French settlement began in the 1830s after France seized Algeria from the Ottoman Empire. Over the decades, tens of thousands of French settlers along with impoverished Italians, Spaniards, Maltese, as well as French criminals sentenced to transportation (that is deportation to the colonies), made up the European..."

2. Algeria, the Assassination of Charles De Gaulle, and the Day of the Jackal (Part 2 of 2) by Charles McCain

"+ A young Harki in uniform in the summer of 1961. While this is going on, Algeria started to come apart. Many of the French, especially those in Algeria itself, thought the colony would be content to remain part of France. This turned out to be incorrect. In 1954, Algerian rebels began an armed insurrection against the French which went on until 1962. Hundreds of thousands of people were killed with some estimates as high as 1,500,000, the majority of whom were Algerians. Part of this number includes an estimated 150,000 to 200,000 native Algerians who were murdered by their..."

3. Diary Entry 32: Saigon, Thursday Night, 22 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Thursday Night, 22 July 1965Did not write last night as we had a conference with a JCS study team here from Washington until 10:30 p.m. By the time I got back to the BOQ about 11, I was pooped out and went right to bed. Today has been a long one, too, but not quite as bad as yesterday. Got home at 8 p.m. and am going to fix some supper just as soon as I finish this. The way things are happening so fast around here, it is hard to keep important events sorted out in my..."

4. Photo: Clark and Brigadier General John D. Crowley, Macv J-4, at Macv I Headquarters, 22 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"I had just said: 'Now that I've got promoted [to lieutenant colonel], I'll now give you all the bad news about how bad off we really are. . .then you can court-martial me!' Then General Crowley said: 'Bad news is all I ever get around here!' And we were all laughing, Clark, right, wrote on the back of this photograph of himself and Brigadier General John D. Crowley, the MACV Assistant Chief of Staff for Logistics (J-4), left, at MACV I Headquarters, 22 July 1965. (Photo courtesy U.S. Army)..."

5. Diary Entry 33: Saigon, Friday Night, 23 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Friday Night, 23 July 1965 This has been a busy but very productive day. Feel like I accomplished a good bit. Did my part in the paperwork and ceremony battle! Regarding the landings of the 2nd Brigade, 1st Infantry Division: Was at Vung Tau where the main force arrived. We put them ashore by LSTs and then flew them to Bien Hoa Air Base, north of Saigon. This was an expensive way to do it, but it was the safest way. I feel pretty good about planning this move and not getting a single person hurt during my part..."

6. Diary Entry 34: Saigon, Saturday Night, 24 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Saturday Night, 24 July 1965 This has been the nicest Saturday that I’ve known since arriving in Vietnam! I finished up all my work by 6 p.m., had something to eat at the Hong Kong BOQ mess, and am now at my BOQ. We didn’t have a single flap today and it was just plain pleasant at the office for a change. Sure hope it stays that way. Things are going so good that I am planning to take the day off tomorrow and do some shopping. Major [Raymond] Kostner, the chief of my Sealift Coordination Center, has offered..."

7. Frequently Mentioned Persons: Lieutenant Colonel Lloyd L. Burke, U.S. Army by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"On 24 July 1965, Clark wrote:"Scooter Burke was wounded today [Burke was wounded on 22 July]. He’s a Medal of Honor winner from Korea, in 1951. I’ve known him for a long time, and he’s just crazy enough to get himself killed. It’s a real good thing he got wounded and is being evacuated, because he takes such needless risks that sooner or later he would have been killed. He had no business being where he was and doing what he was doing when he got wounded. That's lieutenant's work. Lieutenant Colonel Lloyd L. Burke, U.S. Army [pictured as..."

8. Diary Entry 35: Saigon, Sunday Night, 25 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Sunday Night, 25 July 1965Lots of difference between Korea in 1950 and Vietnam 1965. In 1950 I could march 25 miles a day with a full pack and stay up most of the night listening for trouble. In 1965 as a lieutenant colonel, get to feeling washed out by 10 p.m. and haven’t even done any fighting! I believe that I feel better and look better in the field because I’m out in the field walking and looking and being a soldier. There are few pressures on you out in the boondocks other than staying alert. Clark as a..."

9. Diary Entry 36: Saigon, Wednesday Night, 28 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Wednesday Night, 28 July 1965This has been a pretty pleasant day for Vietnam. And on reflection tonight, it is kinda hard to say whether the pleasant aspects are due to: 1) General Crowley’s being away in Hawaii; 2) The VC being quiet; or, 3) my very outstanding managerial talent. On careful consideration of all aspects, I’m inclined to believe that it is due to me. Maybe I have a few things under control now.This has been a light work day. This morning was spent on paperwork such as preparing a staff study, writing some messages to the JCS and..."

10. From the Editor: the President's News Conference, East Room, the White House, 28 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"On 28 July 1965, Clark wrote, The President is going to speak here at midnight tonight, so will stay up to hear him. Bet he’ll say that the situation in South Vietnam causes him 'concern,' that more US troops will be committed, and that some Reserves and National Guard will be called up. So will take a shower and turn the radio on. This is what Clark heard when President Lyndon B. Johnson held his forty-seventh news conference in the East Room of the White House at 12:34 p.m. (12:34 a.m. on 29 July, Saigon time):My..."

11. Diary Entry 37: Saigon, Thursday Night, 29 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Thursday Night, 29 July 1965Today has been what I call “plans and problems day.” What time wasn’t spent on planning was spent with problems. And plans took the biggest part. Morning was spent planning on 3 operations. [The first operation was the arrival and throughput of the 1st Brigade, 101st Airborne Division, which arrived at Cam Ranh Bay today---29 July. The second operation was Operation HIGHLAND, in which the 1st Brigade was to secure a base at An Khe for the 1st Cavalry Division (Airmobile), which was en route from Fort Benning, Georgia. Three areas required the paratroopers..."

12. Diary Entry 38: Saigon, Friday Night, 30 July 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Friday Night, 30 July 1965 Working late tonight at the office, but got tired of the work and decided to take a few minutes off to write. At 10 p.m. I am to go over to MACV I headquarters to brief General DePuy (J-3) and Lieutenant General [John] Throckmorton (Deputy Commander MACV) on some items we have going on. [Clark briefed the generals on the progress of the debark and throughput of the 1st Brigade, 101st Airborne Division, logistic support for Operation HIGHLAND, and plans for the arrival of the 1st Cavalry Division (Airmobile).] Probably be a long..."

13. Diary Entry 39: en Route to Da Nang, Sunday Afternoon, 1 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"En Route to Da Nang Sunday Afternoon, 1 August 1965This trip came up rather suddenly yesterday afternoon, so here I am in a very nice plane just a few minutes off the ground at Tan Son Nhut. Destination is Da Nang where will have some discussions tomorrow with Major General [Lewis] Walt and Brigadier General [Frederick] Karch, US Marine Corps. Expect to arrive Da Nang about 5 p.m. Will return to Saigon Monday night. Colonel [Arthur] Hurow is going up with me. Brought my camera along, but so far no opportunity to take any pictures. We were in kind of..."

14. Diary Entry 40: Saigon, Tuesday Night, 3 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Tuesday Night, 3 August 1965Back from Da Nang all in one piece! Got back to Saigon last night about 10 p.m. but was just too worn out to write when I got in. Went to sleep right in my dirty old fatigues. We programmed the flight back at night on purpose because it is a long way and mostly over VC jungle territory. They can’t see too well way up in the sky at night. Seemed the best time to travel.  Brigadier General Frederick Karch, U.S. Marine Corps (Photo courtesy U.S. Marine Corps). The purpose of the trip was..."

Post-Cold-War

1. Gates on Coin: What Was Really Said? by David Ucko

"There has been ample coverage of Secretary of Defense Robert Gates’ final speech to the West Point cadets last Friday, with much of the attention focusing on an apparently growing disenchantment with counterinsurgency, a theme previously touched upon on this blog. For obvious reasons, the quotation that got the most play in the press was Gates’ quip that any future sec-def who advises the sending of ‘a big American land army into Asia or into the Middle East or Africa should “have his head examined”’. This sentence has been picked up upon as a candid admission by a straight..."

Misc/Thematic

1. Are Lpd-17s Modern-Day Mitschers? by Craig Hooper

"It is always easy to point at the latest shipbuilding “disaster” and claim that it is the “greatest” fiasco ever. It’s true that smaller-scale shipbuilding SNAFUS are a fact of life. But these days, to some observers, mistakes are a distinguishing characteristic of naval shipbuilding. The big “disaster” of my era is the LPD-17. But the LPD-17 saga, according to Navy Institute Uber-Scribe and author of the Naval Institute Guide to Combat Fleets of the World, Eric Wertheim, is not unique. Wertheim was quoted in the LPD-17 article I was quoted in and discussed earlier..."

2. Cdr Paul Milius and Observation Squadron 67 by NHHC

"During the Vietnam War, how to interdict the men and material North Vietnam sent south through neutral Laos and Cambodia proved to be one of the most vexing challenges faced by the United States military. In the Fall of 1966, Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara requested that Army Lieutenant General Alfred Starbird, Director, Defense Communications [...]..."


Monday, March 7, 2011 - 17:03

The 152nd edition of the Military History Digest. Suggestions for military history weblogs to follow are always welcome.

Contents

Long 19th Century

1. Post-Blogging the Chinese Revolution of 1911 by Brett Holman

"At Frog in a Well China, Alan Baumler is post-blogging the Chinese Revolution of 1911, beginning with a premature mutiny in Canton. It should make a nice companion series to David Silbey's earlier effort on the Boxer Uprising. ..."

2. The Question of Inevitability I: the Coming of the War by Brooks D. Simpson

"Folks disagree over whether the Civil War was inevitable. I think there are questions that need to be answered when asking about Civil War causation, because I think we need to prove what is often assumed. So I want to …"

3. The Question of Inevitability II: the Civil War by Brooks D. Simpson

"Historians who try to explain Union victory and Confederate defeat during the Civil War approach that question by asking several questions (or at least implicitly offering their answers). The first question is whether Union victory and Confederate defeat were, in … Continue reading →..."

4. The Question of Inevitability III: Reconstruction by Brooks D. Simpson

"For many years Reconstruction historiography was the story of lost opportunity. Yes, there was the rather predictable retelling of scholarly and semischolarly understandings of the conflict from the beginning of the twentieth century, usually starting with a recapitulation of the … Continue reading →..."

5. Eric Foner on Reconstruction by Brooks D. Simpson

"Given this morning’s post on Reconstruction, I’m hoping that these three videos featuring Eric Foner’s views on Reconstruction will help spark reflection and discussion. Once again, thet come from the Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History. In the first video … Continue reading →..."

6. Disunion – a Jewish View of American Slavery by Donald Shaffer

"Yesterday’s Disunion in the New York Times has a noteworthy essay by Adam Goodheart on Morris J. Raphall, rabbi of New York City’s B’nai Jeshurun synagogue during the Civil War era. In January 1861, Raphall had delivered and published an address entitled, “The Bible View of Slavery.” In it, Raphall reluctantly concluded the Torah justified slavery. Goodheart writes: The learned sage delved deep into the Hebrew Bible – citing the books of Leviticus, Deuteronomy, Job and even Exodus – before concluding that “slaveholding is not only recognized and sanctioned as an integral part of the social structure … [but] the property in slaves..."

7. An Account of the First Day of the Battle of Hampton Roads by gordon.b.calhoun@navy.mil (Gordon Calhoun)

"On this anniversary of the Battle of Hampton Roads, we presented a slightly different account of the battle. Below is a partial account as told by Henry Reaney, a volunteer U.S. Naval officer. At the time of the battle, Reaney was serving as the commanding officer of the armed tug USS Zouave. His ship was one of several armed tugs assigned to U.S. Naval blockading forces in Hampton Roads. The U.S. Navy's mishandling of the tugs was one of the reasons for the loss of both Cumberland and Congress, as the they were suppose to help the large warships manuever..."

8. Day 1 (Ctd.) and Day 2 of the Battle of Hampton Roads Weekend by matthew.t.eng@navy.mil (Matthew T. Eng)

"NEWS FROM THE FRONT! (Continued Day 1)March 5, 2011 1:00 pm: Attended the second lecture of the day focusing on the efforts of the Blockade during the Civil War. The 1:00 lecture centered on the role of the Grey Ghost, CSS Alabama, and its operations throughout its storied history. Dr. William S. Dudley, former director of the Naval Historical Center (now the Naval History and Heritage Command), was the speaker for the event. After discussing the elements that surround the theories of Union and Confederate strategy and sea power at the start of the war, Dr. Dudley..."

9. "The First of Iron-Clads," John Taylor Wood by matthew.t.eng@navy.mil (Matthew T. Eng)

"Currier & Ives IllustrationToday marks the 149th anniversary of the storied engagement between the USS Monitor and CSS Virginia. The following is an excerpt from an account of the Monitor and Virginia (Titled The First of Iron-Clads) from John Taylor Wood, CSA. No changes have been made to the original text to keep with the historical integrity of the document. Excerpt from"The First of Iron-Clads" But at daybreak we discovered, lying between us and the Minnesota, a strange-looking craft, which we knew at once to be Ericson's Monitor, which had long been expected in Hampton Roads, and..."

10. William Waldie by Steve Soper

"William Waldie was born in 1836 in Scotland or Canada, the son of James (b. 1814) and Isabelle (b. 1817).Scottish-born James married English-born Isabelle sometime before the late 1830s when they were living in Canada where they resided for many years. They were probably living in Canada in 1848 when their son Adam was born and in 1856 when their son george was born. The family reportedly came to Michigan, settling first at Otter Lake near Flint in Genesee County, before moving on to the western side of the state. Nevertheless, it does appear that they did..."

11. The Predictable Press by Brooks D. Simpson

"In December 2005 I was sitting in my office at ASU, minding my own business, tying up loose ends from the fall semester, when the phone rang. It was a reporter from the Christian Science Monitor. He wanted to discuss … Continue reading →..."

12. Slavery in the Permanent Confederate Constitution by Donald Shaffer

"On March 11, 1861, the Confederate Congress, meeting in Montgomery, Alabama, adopted a permanent constitution for their new nation to supersede the provisional constitutional they had hastily adopted a little over a month before. Civil War Emancipation has already dealt with the latter document as it pertained to slavery. Today, it will deal with the permanent constitution on the same issue. Like the provisional constitution, it was largely based on the U.S. Constitution, but with significant differences. As Stephanie McCurry writes in yesterday’s Disunion in the New York Times, “They purged the text of all of the ambivalences, compromises and..."

13. Professor Edward C. Smith’s Black Confederates by Kevin Levin

"Yesterday I was pleasantly surprised to receive an email from one of Professor Edward C. Smith’s current students. Professor Smith teaches at American University and on occasion has been a vocal advocate of the black Confederate narrative. He was featured not too long ago in a post that included an excerpt of a speech he [...]..."

14. Rodney Wampole by Steve Soper

"Rodney Wampole was born on July 30, 1843, in Livingston County, New York, the son of John (b. 1804) and Elizabeth (b. 1814). (The 1920 census lists his birth place as Canada and the online burial record for Washington State veterans’ homes lists his birthplace as Ontario, Canada.)Pennsylvania native John married New York-born Elizabeth sometime before 1833 probably in New York where their daughter Matilda was born. The family resided in New York for many years and by 1850 Rodney was living on the family farm in West Sparta, Livingston County, New York.Rodney was possibly the same Rodney..."

15. The Cavalry Commander by The General

"From General August V. Kautz’s war-time manual, Customs of Service for Officers of the Army, we have Kautz’s list of the qualifications required for a good cavalry commander. As Kautz himself was a cavalryman, this makes for an interesting list. 687. CAVALRY.—A Cavalry Commander requires peculiar qualifications, that are far more rare than for any other arm of the service. He should, first of all, be young, and of fine physical qualities, capable of enduring great fatigue. He should be quick of thought and decision, without being rash; he should be able to form his plans rapidly and..."

16. Digging Up the Truth by Jay Jaffe

"Abner Doubleday had nothin' to do with it. A few weeks ago, Major League Baseball did something right by naming John Thorn its Official Historian. Best known as the author and editor of the Total Baseball encyclopedia series and the senior creative consultant on Ken Burns’ Baseball series (where he got plenty of face time), Thorn is the sport’s preeminent scholar, a methodical researcher who talks a good game as well. Nowhere has his work been more important than in unraveling — and subsequently reconstructing — its official history. Suffice it to say that everything you thought you knew about Abner Doubleday..."

17. Roger Taney Does a Good Deed by Donald Shaffer

"Roger B. Taney, Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court in 1861, is probably best remembered for writing the majority opinion in the infamous Dred Scott decision and its atrocious statement that black people “had no rights which the white man was bound to respect.” Yet on March 14, 1861, he delivered the majority opinion for the U.S. Supreme Court in Kentucky v. Dennison considerably friendlier to African Americans, by implication if not by design. The case involved extradition law and whether federal courts could compel state governors to honor warrants of extradition from other states. The case had begun..."

World War I

1. World War One Navy Recruiting Posters by Charles McCain

"A constant theme throughout the history of the United States is the need for manpower for the armed services. To this end, there have always been recruiting efforts and the most simple and straight forward of these has been the poster. No matter which era they are from, they repeat a common message - do your duty and serve your country because only through your help can we win. Over the next few weeks, I will be providing some examples of these recruiting posters as they pertain to the Navy. The following posters are from World War One and feature images..."

World War II

1. Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy and the Governance of Italy, 1861-1946 by Charles McCain

Fast forward to 7 December 1941,"a date which will live in infamy," when the Japanese made their sneak attack on Pearl Harbor. On 8 December 1941, at the request of President Roosevelt, the Congress declared war on Japan. And only Japan. Here's the really interesting part of which many are not aware: on 11 December 1941, in a coordinated announcement, Italy and then Germany, declared war on..."

2. Incompetence, Stupidity, and Cowardice: the Royal House of Savoy and the Governance of Italy, 1861-1946 by Charles McCain

Intellectuals whom the Fascist government of Italy thought would undermine them, or had spoken against them, were sent into internal exile in distant mountain villages, mainly in Southern Italy. Once brought to the village by the police, the intellectual offender could not leave or communicate with the outside world, at least not formally. The suicidal boredom of such a situation, the pettiness of the quarrels..."

3. Profile 46 -"Satan's Chillen" by wily1@mac.com (JSM)

"The study sketch above is of a B-17G that flew with the 401st Bomb Group based at Deenethorpe, Northhamptonshire, England. Specifically, the bomber belonged to the 613th Squadron. But, if you're really, really into the details, her serial number was 43-37706 and was accepted into the U.S. Army Air Force inventory on May 13, 1944.Today, all that's left of this bomber resides in the minds of her two surviving air crew, pilot Lt. William Mannix and bombardier,"Dick" Rostrom.The closest I've gotten to the bomber's pilot was a scratchy phone call to Mannix's wife - her husband was..."

4. Profile 46 -"Satan's Chillen" by wily1@mac.com (JSM)

"I couldn't bear the previous paltry sketch, so I fleshed out the study a bit tonight. These little pencil sketches are important to me because they help train my mind for the airplane's proportions.Bombers have never been my 'thing.' Temperament-wise, I can't imagine the idea of riding along in what is essentially a military bus, stuck to my office. Sitting or standing for a 3, 4, 5, 6 hour mission is hard to fathom, don't you think?There's an interesting analog between a WW2 bomber and many people's work environment - their cubicle, their office, is their position. Pilot, bombardier..."

5. Wednesday, 12 March 1941 by Brett Holman

"The Glasgow Herald, like many early-twentieth-century 'provincial' newspapers, made a serious effort to cover war and other international news, as well as reporting on national and local issues. (In fact, it almost seems more interested in what's happening overseas than it is in London or even Edinburgh.) Its highmindedness is also evident in its lack of interest in trivialities (no sports section today!) and in its rather staid appearance, with the outside pages taken up with classified ads, and the news and editorials at the centre of its twelve page. The Herald might be excused for its old..."

6. Thursday, 13 March 1941 by Brett Holman

"The Glasgow Herald today again leads with Lease-and-Lend, specifically the massive appropriation request made by Roosevelt to Congress -- over half a billion pounds' worth of 'aircraft and aeronautical material, including engines, spares, and accessories' alone (5). The Bill will be ready for debate early next week: the Speak of the House of Representatives, Sam Rayburn, promised 'We are going to put everything else aside'. Of course, the passing of Lease-and-Lend was welcomed here in Britain. Churchill, with a degree of historical inexactitude, likened it to the Magna Carta. His speech was 'spoken with that artistic perfection..."

7. Friday, 14 March 1941 by Brett Holman

"The big news today is that the latest Italian offensive against Greek forces in the Tepelini sector has been a disaster. War correspondents estimate 10,000 Italian casualties, including 2000 dead; yet 'it was stated in authoritative circles in London yesterday that the Italians do not appear to have made any perceptible progress' (5). This is despite (perhaps there's a hint of because of) Mussolini's presence at the front lines over the last few days, 'leading or encouraging the Italian troops'. Greek spirits are understandably high. Looking at the bigger picture in the Mediterranean, the Herald's military correspondent suggests that the..."

8. Saturday, 15 March 1941 by Brett Holman

"The war news today is much closer to home for the Glasgow Herald than usual. A big air raid last night on 'a Central district of Scotland' (5) is vividly described, as though the reporter had witnessed it: readers would know for themselves just how far away it was. One Nazi 'plane which appeared to be heading for home was spotted by searchlights, and immediately there was a road of gunfire as battery after battery opened up and poured shells into the apex of the searchlights. The crackle of bursting shells followed a maze of flashes. When the gunfire stopped..."

9. German Type 212A U-Boat by Charles McCain

The technological prowess of the Type 212A U-Boat can be directly traced back to research made in the latter half of World War Two with the development of the Type XXI U-Boat. Designed as a true submarine rather than as a surface ship that could submerge for short periods of time, the Type XXI was technically and technologically more sophisticated than the Type VII U-Boat. Many of the advances incorporated into its design included: a substantial increase in battery capacity and recharging ability; a more streamlined and hydro-dynamically clean..."

Cold War

1. Best Defense Bookshelf: 'Fragging,' the Vietnam War's Characteristic Crime by Thomas E. Ricks

"Just when you think there is not much new to say about a subject, along comes a book that overhauls your understanding of that subject. I say this because I just finished Fragging: Why U.S. Soldiers Assaulted Their Officers in Vietnam, by George Lepre. I've been reading about Vietnam full-time now since early last summer, and so wasn't surprised to see how the Army fell apart in Vietnam, for example going from 47 drug apprehensions of soldiers there in 1965 to 11,058 in 1970. (P. 113) Or that one U.S. Army division, the ill-fated Americal, in 1970 had..."

2. Diary Entry 41: Saigon, Saturday Morning, 7 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Saturday Morning, 7 August 1965Just been as busy as a one-armed paper hanger and plain tired out. Activity is stepping up here so fast it takes 18-20 hours a day to keep things under control. So many things happen that it is hard to remember what I have done. Guess that must be a sign of getting old! Either that or so many things happen that you just get lost in the maze of events. So let’s see if I can tax my brain and recall what has happened since I last wrote.Wednesday morning took a flight..."

3. Diary Entry 42: Saigon, Sunday Night, 8 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Sunday Night, 8 August 1965Yesterday, Saturday, spent the morning working over staff papers and had a quick sandwich at the desk for lunch. After lunch had to go over to MACV I to see General [William B.] Rosson, [MACV] Chief of Staff, about USOM rice shipments. Interesting discussion but mostly one-way---chief did most of the talking and I did the listening.   Major General William B. Rosson, U.S. Army, MACV Chief of Staff [pictured here as a general]. (Photo courtesy U.S. Army)  Later on had a meeting at our office with a bunch of people about ammo discharge..."

4. From the Editor: Letter, General William C. Westmoreland, to Lieutenant Colonel Richard P. Clark, Jr., 5 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"This letter was typed on onionskin typing paper and deteriorated between 1965 and the present day. The editor scanned the fragments of the letter, converted the image from color to black-and-white, and digitally repaired the image so it resembles, as best as possible, the original document. Note that the letter was addressed to J-2 (Intelligence), rather than J-4 (Logistics). (Document courtesy Richard P. Clark, Jr. collection)..."

5. Diary Entry 43: Saigon, Wednesday Night, 11 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Wednesday Night, 11 August 1965This may not be a very long entry tonight as I get interrupted by frequent phone calls every 15 or 20 minutes. We’ve had a rough tactical emergency going since early yesterday at Pleiku and Duc Co. As usual, everybody wants airplanes and we don’t have enough to go around. Our scheduled operations were shut down completely and I have had only a few hours sleep in the last 48 hours. Spent most of my time over in the J-3 Combat Operations Center trying to keep up with the situation. Had good company. [Lieutenant..."

6. From the Editor: the Siege of Duc Co, 10-17 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"In early August 1965, the Viet Cong encircled a U.S. Army Special Forces camp at Duc Co, west of Pleiku, and attacked a South Vietnamese military relief convoy on Highway 19 between Pleiku and Duc Co. [See map.] Movements Branch programmed U.S. Air Force C-123 flights that made airdrops along the highway, resupplied the blocked convoy, and made paradrops of supplies and medical equipment to the besieged camp. As Clark noted in his diary on 7 August, one C-123 aircraft received mortar damage and more than twenty small-arms hits during a medical evacuation at Duc Co. The..."

7. Are Lpd-17s Modern-Day Mitschers? by Craig Hooper

"It is always easy to point at the latest shipbuilding “disaster” and claim that it is the “greatest” fiasco ever. It’s true that smaller-scale shipbuilding SNAFUS are a fact of life. But these days, to some observers, mistakes are a distinguishing characteristic of naval shipbuilding. The big “disaster” of my era is the LPD-17. But the LPD-17 saga, according to Navy Institute Uber-Scribe and author of the Naval Institute Guide to Combat Fleets of the World, Eric Wertheim, is not unique. Wertheim was quoted in the LPD-17 article I was quoted in and discussed earlier..."

8. Diary Entry 44: Saigon, Friday Night, 13 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Friday Night, 13 August 1965This has certainly been a good day. Had a successful promotion party at the Hong Kong BOQ and everybody seemed to have a good time. Two brigadier generals, Crowley and Reichel, came early.Well, it was a good day up to the time of the above half-paragraph. Then I got a call from BG DePuy, the J-3 (Assistant Chief of Staff for Military Operations) to come over to his office right away and discuss airlift with him. Did just as he requested and now it is just a little past 1 a.m. and am..."

9. Frequently Mentioned Persons: Brigadier General John D. Crowley, Jr., U.S. Army Transportation Corps, Macv J-4, 1965-1966 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Brigadier General John Denis Crowley, Jr., U.S. Army Transportation Corps, was the MACV assistant chief of staff for logistics (J-4), from February 1965 to August 1966. He was the principal staff logistical officer responsible for all ammunition, construction, supply, maintenance, medical services, fuel, and transportation in South Vietnam. [1] In 1965, Jack Crowley reached a high point in a career in which his fortunes rose and fell with the suddenness of a roller coaster. Born in Boston in 1916, Crowley enlisted in the Army in 1934 and served in the 5th Infantry in 1934. In 1938, Crowley won appointment..."

10. Diary Entry 45: Saigon, Tuesday Night, 17 August 1965 by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"Saigon Tuesday Night, 17 August 1965 Since last Saturday, we’ve just been real busy almost up to midnight thrashing out some plans. Have even been a very bad host as I had company visit with me Sunday and Monday and the host just didn’t treat them the way he should have. [Major] Jim Greenquist and [Major] Harry the Horse [Brockman] were my guests Sunday and Monday. I had told each of them to come by and see me whenever in Saigon and they both showed up the same day. Commercial hotel rooms in Saigon are either too expensive ($20..."

11. From the Editor:"Discipline Is in Order": Sexually Transmitted Diseases and Macv, 1965. by noreply@blogger.com (J.R. Clark)

"On 17 August 1965, Clark wrote:"Sergeant Heizman, who is newly assigned to the Sealift Center, has been reported from the hospital as having been treated for VD, so tomorrow he will probably be PFC Drake’s replacement as discipline is in order. This is a fascinating statement if we look back at a diary entry on 14 June 1965 in which Clark described the different branches that comprised the Transportation Division of MACV J-4:"The office:Brigadier General Crowley (TC) J-4Colonel Smith (Inf) Deputy J-4Colonel Plate (USAF) Trans OffMajor Clark (TC) Chief Movements BranchMajor Beaver (USAF) Air Force..."

Misc/Thematic

1. New Owner Sought for Historic Warship Olympia by The Associated Press

"PHILADELPHIA — A historic warship in Philadelphia is looking for a new owner...."

2. Transatlantic Flight Record by Naval Institute Archives

"March, 15th 1957 Goodyear N-class ZPG-2 airship, commanded by Commander J. R. Hunt, landed at NAS Key West, Florida after a flight that began on March, 4th at South Weymouth, Massachusetts. The flight continued over the Atlantic toward Portugal, then south toward the African coast and back across the Atlantic covering 9,448 miles and remaining [...]..."

3. Million-Man Training by NHHC

"On 14 March 1943 the Fleet Operational Training Command, Atlantic Fleet was formally established, with Rear Admiral Donald B. Beary in command. Beary, known as “Red” to his fellow Naval Academy graduates of the Class of 1910, came to the new assignment from a seventh-month stint as Commandant of the Naval Operating Base in Iceland. [...]..."


Tuesday, March 15, 2011 - 11:41