George Mason University's
History News Network
Reagan Library Debate
Republicans have hit upon a great idea: scheduling debates at presidential libraries.

But they should be braver.

How about holding their next debate at the Nixon Library? And the one after that at the Hoover Library.

Democrats could hold theirs at the Carter Library.

Of course, I am in fantasyland. Political parties are only interested in the libraries of presidents who succeeded. No one wants to "get right" with Nixon, Hoover, or Carter. And I would bet that there will never be a Republican Party debate held at the future George W. Bush Library. No one will want to "get right" with George W. Bush.

Getting right with former (and usually dead) presidents is an old American tradition. The first president pols wanted to get right with was Andrew Jackson. Two successors, Martin van Buren and James K. Polk, may be said to have owed their election in part to their ability to associate themselves with Jackson. Polk was even known as Young Hickory.


David Donald, in perhaps his most famous essay, "Getting Right with Lincoln," showed the remarkable ways in which Radical Republicans used Lincoln to advance their agenda after his assassination. While he was alive they barely tolerated him. Wendell Phillips, the fiery abolitionist, called Lincoln "a first-rate second-rate man." But when he died they used the occasion of his three-week funeral to adopt him as their own and blame Democrats for his murder.

For the next half century Republicans of all stripes, radical, conservative and in-between, sought Lincoln's endorsement, as Donald aptly put it, in their runs for the White House. A strange assortment of pols including McKinley, Harding and Coolidge, whose resemblance to Lincoln was hard to fathom, claimed possession of the Springfield hero as a partisan right.

Democrats, whose political base was the Solid South, did not contest the Republicans' ownership of Lincoln. The Great Emancipator was political poison to too many of their natural consituents. So Lincoln remained a partisan symbol well into the twentieth century. Not until Woodrow Wilson, the first Southerner elected president since the Civil War, did a Democrat celebrate Lincoln and attempt to borrow against his prestige. That was more than half a century after Lincoln's death.

Today Lincoln is everybody's hero. One day Ronald Reagan will be too.


Presidential Libraries, Presidential Foundations

Tim, you ask "Can a library control someone's legacy by disallowing a function such as those suggested above?" Presidential Libraries are hybrids, government-run and taxpayer financed but with private funds being used for some of the activities associated with them. In asking about control of legancies, and decisions on how to use Libraries, are you referring to the National Archives and Records Administration (the nonpartisan federal agency which staffs and runs the Presidential Libraries) or the Presidential family foundations which support some of the Libraries' museum and other outreach activities?

Given their differing perspectives, goals and objectives, I never would assume that the two entities view everything the same way. Of course, the public cannot which of the two calls the shots on what. Note what the former director of a Presidential Library writes at
http://hnn.us/roundup/entries/35248.html

Professor Benjamin Hufbauer currently has a piece up at the Bushlibraryblog with his take on the history of Presidential Libraries, including some interesting tidbits about FDR's Library, see
http://shrinkster.com/oqx

Advocating Crossover?

Rick,

So, you're saying that Democrats might be well served by asking to hold a debate at Reagan's Library? I think someone with a creative mind, such as Obama or Hillary, could pull it off. Would a centrist Republican, in turn (i.e. Huckabee?), be well served by holding forth at FDR's library?

Can a library control someone's legacy by disallowing a function such as those suggested above? Is it a function of their status that they have to allow, within reason, audiences and functions of all stripes? Hmm...

- Tim

Re: Advocating Crossover?

It took Lincoln half a century to become a national non-partisan hero.

I suspect it will take Reagan just as long.

There's no chance any Democrats would want to participate in a debate at the Reagan library in this election.