Return to Hurd on Same-Sex Marriage

Failing, or changing (#47300)
by Jonathan Dresner on November 23, 2004 at 3:02 PM
I just want to point out a fallacy in Hurd's argument against marriage: a 50% divorce rate doesn't mean that marriage as an institution is failing, unless by marriage he means marriage-for-life, which never worked all that well anyway. Yes, there's a lot of irrationality around marriage, but there'd be a lot of irrationality around almost any marriage-surrogate for the foreseeable future, too.

Re: Failing, or changing (#47306)
by Chris Matthew Sciabarra on November 23, 2004 at 3:58 PM
Actually, I agree. And we certainly wouldn't want a situation where people felt obliged to stay married... to avoid the "stigma" of divorce, damaging each other and their children in the process of raising one big unhappy dysfunctional family.

Post a Comment

What rules govern discussion boards?

If you have not already done so, you must Sign Up before you can post.








Return to Hurd on Same-Sex Marriage

CHNM ad

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

 

HNN Donations--click here.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Just How Stupid Are We? By Rick Shenkman

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.