Return to Peter Schwartz and the Abandonment of Rand’s Radical Legacy, Part V

Schwartz's statism (#48494)
by Geoffrey Allan Plauche on December 10, 2004 at 11:11 AM
"To lead the Iraqis to freedom, whether in the next year or the next generation, requires that we “impose” our values on them—i.e., that we expose them to the philosophy of a free society. They need to be given the Declaration of Independence to study. Their schools must teach the ideas of Thomas Jefferson and John Locke and Adam Smith. The Governing Council must be instructed to eject the communists and the jihadists." (51)

Here's a perfect example of Schwartz's statism. He may be an advocate of limited government at home, but he advocates the opposite abroad: a thoroughly statist foreign policy orientation that will be counterproductive at best.

Excellent series, Chris. I appreciate the emphasis on Rand's radical, dialectic legacy. I'm curious, however, if you know whether and to what extent Rand's recognition of the interrelationship between domestic and foreign policy was informed by Mises's work on this particular issue.

Re: Schwartz's statism (#48513)
by Chris Matthew Sciabarra on December 10, 2004 at 3:07 PM
Thanks for your comments, Geoffrey. I don't have any information on a Rand-Mises link that is specifically relevant to the domestic-foreign policy interrelationship. But Rand surely read Mises, and recommended his work highly; among the books that are listed in her Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal bibliography, one will find these Mises titles:

The Anti-Capitalistic Mentality

Human Action

Omnipotent Government

Planned Chaos

Planning for Freedom

Socialism

The Theory of Money and Credit

Re: Schwartz's statism (#48517)
by Geoffrey Allan Plauche on December 10, 2004 at 3:58 PM
Quite so. I was just wondering whether Rand developed (at least in part) her ideas on the subject before reading Mises's work or whether the picked it up from him. Academic curiosity on my part.

Post a Comment

What rules govern discussion boards?

If you have not already done so, you must Sign Up before you can post.








Return to Peter Schwartz and the Abandonment of Rand’s Radical Legacy, Part V

CHNM ad

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

 

HNN Donations--click here.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Just How Stupid Are We? By Rick Shenkman

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.