Return to Thoughts on Sciabarra

Anarchism and Libertarianism (#52413)
by Jude D Blanchette on February 4, 2005 at 4:53 PM
I completely agree with Dr. Horwitz on both counts. However, I think there must be a much firmer distinction between the terms "anarchist" and "libertarian." Libertarianism as a doctrine is simply the extension of liberalism. At its core, it holds a belief in the state, albeit an aggressively limited one. This is in distinction with anarchism (or anarcho-capitalism, or market anarchism, etc.). While there is certainly a fair amount of agreement between the two groups, they are two distinct concepts and for the purpose of verbal clarity, there should be a strict delineation.

Re: Anarchism and Libertarianism (#52414)
by John T. Kennedy on February 4, 2005 at 5:00 PM
Statism is an early mistake of liberalism, but that doesn't make it the core.

Re: Anarchism and Libertarianism (#52424)
by Jason Kuznicki on February 4, 2005 at 7:06 PM
Historically, it is preposterous to say that statism is an early mistake of liberalism--as if any bona fide theory of anarchism existed in the days of Grotius, Hobbes, and Locke. It just didn't happen that way. Liberalism has almost always contained a theory of the state in some form, and anarchists have generally considered this a fundamental difference between themselves and liberals.

You may argue that anarchism is preferable to statism--and even to a minarchist liberalism--but that's quite another issue.

Post a Comment

What rules govern discussion boards?

If you have not already done so, you must Sign Up before you can post.








Return to Thoughts on Sciabarra

CHNM ad

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

 

HNN Donations--click here.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Just How Stupid Are We? By Rick Shenkman

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.