Return to Thoughts on Sciabarra

Anarchism and Libertarianism (#52413)
by Jude D Blanchette on February 4, 2005 at 4:53 PM
I completely agree with Dr. Horwitz on both counts. However, I think there must be a much firmer distinction between the terms "anarchist" and "libertarian." Libertarianism as a doctrine is simply the extension of liberalism. At its core, it holds a belief in the state, albeit an aggressively limited one. This is in distinction with anarchism (or anarcho-capitalism, or market anarchism, etc.). While there is certainly a fair amount of agreement between the two groups, they are two distinct concepts and for the purpose of verbal clarity, there should be a strict delineation.

Re: Anarchism and Libertarianism (#52414)
by John T. Kennedy on February 4, 2005 at 5:00 PM
Statism is an early mistake of liberalism, but that doesn't make it the core.

Re: Anarchism and Libertarianism (#52424)
by Jason Kuznicki on February 4, 2005 at 7:06 PM
Historically, it is preposterous to say that statism is an early mistake of liberalism--as if any bona fide theory of anarchism existed in the days of Grotius, Hobbes, and Locke. It just didn't happen that way. Liberalism has almost always contained a theory of the state in some form, and anarchists have generally considered this a fundamental difference between themselves and liberals.

You may argue that anarchism is preferable to statism--and even to a minarchist liberalism--but that's quite another issue.

Post a Comment

What rules govern discussion boards?

If you have not already done so, you must Sign Up before you can post.








Return to Thoughts on Sciabarra

ASHP-CUNY Banner

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

HNN Donations--click here.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Just How Stupid Are We? By Rick Shenkman

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.

Subscribe to HNN's newsletter.