With support from the University of Richmond

History News Network

History News Network puts current events into historical perspective. Subscribe to our newsletter for new perspectives on the ways history continues to resonate in the present. Explore our archive of thousands of original op-eds and curated stories from around the web. Join us to learn more about the past, now.

Jim Sleeper: The Republic After Obama

Jim Sleeper is a lecturer at Yale University.

Hannah Arendt characterized politics as a realm of "speech-acts," in which words are close enough to deeds so that the words aren't evasive or empty and the deeds aren't mindless or brutal.

In April our national orchestra of high-minded opinion presented President Obama's oration on the deficit as a great speech-act. A chorus of pundits rejoiced that he'd exposed the hypocrisies of Rep. Paul Ryan and other Republican deficit hawks-cum-rollback artists. The orchestra oomph-pah-pah'd its way through its familiar medley, "This Is the Best of All Possible Worlds." After all, it's only an orchestra, not a politically organized force.

I couldn't help feeling -- and warning here, in virtually the same words you're reading now -- that most of what Obama said he stood for was about to be eviscerated by a bought-and-paid-for Congress whose members' words have become so divorced from deeds that brutality has entered the congressional arena itself, as in the Tea Party disruptions of congressional town-hall meetings, not to mention in Tuscon.

The only justifiable answer to what Obama himself called the "hostage takers" in a rare moment of pique would be an electorate that hasn't just been entertained by him in what, in retrospect, was his year-long Michael Jackson concert of 2007-2008, but one that has been educated and mobilized by a truth-telling Great Communicator.

I credit Obama with elevating racial politics. I've never expected him to slay the dragons of the American casino-financed, corporate-welfare, consumer-defrauding juggernaut single-handedly, especially given the damage done by fanatical Republican strategists determined to "starve the beast" of government. But there remains a standard of truth-telling leadership -- the kind that would educate and mobilize a body politic against its hostage takers. It's a standard that Obama has conspicuously failed to meet. Instead, he's been an "Ivy neo-liberal," with grace notes that I and others began worrying about even before his election.

Read entire article at Talking Points Memo