Have Sunnis and Shiites in Iraq Always Been at Each Other's Throats?Google Questions
tags: Iraq, Sunni, Shiite
Imam Ali Holy Shrine (Wiki)
The short answer to the question is: No. But people fall into the trap of thinking that people at war have always been at war. The fact is the overwhelming majority of Iraqis lived as Sunnis until about 200 years ago.
The 'age-old passions' trope is such a convenient plot device that people always fall for it. I remember my friends among the Balkanists being upset when it was applied to Bosnia, where people in recent decades had had perfectly amicable relations.
The conversion of the southern tribes in Iraq to Shiism may have in part been a rebellion against the Sunni Ottoman state, which tried to tax and control them. But actually part of the process became clear to me in my dissertation work. The Shiite shrine cities of Karbala and Najaf are not near water, having been founded because of historical assassinations and tomb visitation rather than economics. Especially in pilgrimage season, there were severe water shortages-- people used to bring water bags on donkey back from the Euphrates and water was expensive.
Because of Safavid Iranian Shiite emigration to Mughal India, many Indian provincial governors were originally from Iran and were Shiites. When the Mughal empire declined from the 1740s, these governors emerged as rulers in their own right, in Bengal, Sindh and Oudh. Shiite notable families went on pilgrimage to Najaf and Karbala, and they minded the lack of water. So in the 1830s they negotiated with the Mamluk vassals of the Ottomans to have canals built to the shrine cities, and they paid for them, using the Shiite clergy as intermediaries and overseers.
The Indian Canals not only brought water to the shrine cities but the pastoral tribes noticed that you could irrigate off them and bring new land under cultivation, so they settled as farmers. They were near the shrine cities, and the clergy sent out missionaries to convert them. They were attracted by the charisma of the Shiite shrine cities and did convert, and then their cousins elsewhere also joined in, and over the 19th century most of southern Iraq became Shiite by a kind of chain conversion. I found correspondence about all this in manuscript libraries in Lucknow in India.
comments powered by Disqus
- 1619 Project: New York Times Magazine Publishes Special Edition Dedicated to American Slavery and Its Legacies
- National Security Archive Releases New Briefing Book on Chernobyl through the Eyes of the Soviet Politburo, KGB, and U.S. Intelligence
- Before Trump eyed Greenland: Here’s what happened last time the US bought a large chunk of the Arctic
- Illinois Governor Signs Bill Mandating Public Schools Teach LGBTQ History
- Controversial Monument to Women’s Suffrage Redesigned to Include Sojourner Truth
- Historian Elizabeth Hinton Profiled in Harvard Magazine: Color and Incarceration
- 'Clearly, he did not take part in our curriculum': Historians bash Ken Cuccinelli's revised Statue of Liberty Poem
- The Increasing Popularity of Hotel Historians
- If You Call It History, You’ve Got to Do History’: Historians Chafe at a Video That Omitted Their University’s Whites-Only Origins
- Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum gets grants to help publish Abraham Lincoln papers