Prep Schools, “Diversity,” and Puritan ConscienceRoundup
tags: Puritans, Groton, Prep Schools
Last month an instructor at the elite Groton School — founded in 1884 by, among others, J.P. Morgan and Endicott Peabody, its first rector, a descendant of Massachusetts Puritans — wrote me to take issue with some kind words I’ve published in this summer’s DEMOCRACY journal (subsequently adapted and posted by The Atlantic) about the Puritan steel in Groton’s bygone rites of passage to maturity and republican leadership as the school understood them .
“Groton is vastly different from Peabody’s school, with its culture of ‘manly Christianity,’” my correspondent sniffed, adding that “If it were anything like the Rector’s institution, I wouldn’t have spent these years teaching here.”
Can anything be said in defense of “manly Christianity” by anyone besides a true believer, especially now that Americans have taken new steps, whether in South Carolina or at the Supreme Court, to broaden our understandings of racial and sexual comity? Wasn’t the pedagogy of old preparatory schools such as Groton so elitist, sexist, and racist that we’re well rid of it?
The old schools’ rigorous disciplines — extra-curricular, as well as curricular — were often unjustified and often misdirected, often hypocritically, and not only because they were institutionally sexist and racist. Some of them, including Groton and Choate, were founded late in the 19th-Century amid a phony revival of Puritanism by Gilded Age plutocrats hoping mainly to toughen their sons to exercise elite prerogatives. ...
comments powered by Disqus
- We Insist: A Century Of Black Music Against State Violence
- The Scars of Being Policed While Black (video)
- Book Reconsideration: “A Confederacy of Dunces” — Still an American Comic Masterpiece?
- Mississippi Governor Signs Law Removing Confederate Design From State Flag
- Trump Doubles Down on 'Heritage' Defense of Confederate Statues
- Living in History: Richard Haass, Margaret MacMillan, and Annette Gordon-Reed
- Beyond ‘White Fragility’: If you Want to Let Freedom Ring, Hammer on Economic Injustice.
- The Best Histories of U.S. Policing, According to Experts
- How Mount Rushmore Became Mount Rushmore
- Princeton University Removes Woodrow Wilson From School Name (Audio)