Historians Lose in Court to Obtain Select Reagan-Era Documents





On 24 September 2004, Judge Kollar-Kotelly of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia issued a ruling on a claim made by historians and archivists in the case “American Historical Association, et al v. National Archives and Records Administration.”

The case focuses on a claim for access to 74 pages (9 documents) of presidential-related “confidential” (P-5 exemption) materials dating back to the administration of Ronald Reagan that President George W. Bush claimed a privilege on and refused to release. In her ruling the judge held that the law required that the plaintiffs had to demonstrate a “special need” to overcome the claim of privilege, and that in spite of the passage of time the special need still has to be asserted; since no such claim was made, summary judgment was granted to the government.

Regarding another count still pending in the original suit made by the historical/archival community -- that the Executive Order 13233 signed by President George W. Bush on 1 November 2001 which purports to “further implement” the Presidential Records Act of 1978 contains illegal provisions -- the judge granted the plaintiffs motion to “reconsider” her earlier order from March 2004 in which she dismissed the case on “ripeness” grounds. Judge Kollar-Kotelly now has directed that the plaintiffs and the government prepare a new round of stand-alone briefings. Public Citizen Litigation Group is preparing the brief that will be submitted on behalf of the plaintiff organizations by the 31 October 2006, the court filing deadline.


comments powered by Disqus
History News Network